Nader's Raters

After reading Richard Goldstein's "Looking for Lefty" [September 19], I wonder how many more articles critical of Ralph Nader and forgiving of Al Gore I am going to have to wade through this year. While mentioning nearly every tired argument the Democrats have wheeled out to bash Nader (the Supreme Court, social conservatism, lesser of two evils, etc.), Goldstein barely mentions that Nader is the only candidate who opposes the death penalty, deregulated trade, the criminalization of marijuana use, corporate control of the electoral system, and unnecessary military spending. The current scaremongering by so-called liberals is disappointing.

Stephen S. Burzio
Baldwin, New York

Duop Ado

While Richard Goldstein's piece on Ralph Nader notes that progressives have the opportunity for minority representation in Europe due to parliamentary systems that enable negotiation in a coalition, the article misses other approaches to address fundamental flaws in the U.S. political system.

Namely, preferential voting systems (where second and subsequent choices figure in the final vote tally) and compulsory voting. These systems are practiced by newer democracies and contribute in no small way to stability while ensuring unrestricted debate.

That Nader identifies problems with the two-party system is applaudable. By running in a first-past-the-post voting system, he illustrates how structurally entrenched the current duopoly is.

Leigh Smith
Greenwich Village

Richard Goldstein replies: I didn't stint on praising Nader, but in my book any progressive who welcomes a Bush victory should be called on it.

Evict Goodman

Re the letter from Michael McKee in last week's issue regarding the endorsement of State Senator Roy M. Goodman by the Tenants Political Action Committee: I don't see how tenants can look at the terrible rent law results in 1997 and support Goodman against housing activist Liz Krueger, the candidate for the Democratic, Green, and Working Families parties.

In 1997, despite a spirited campaign that laid responsibility directly at the doorsteps of Governor George Pataki and Senator Al D'Amato, the rent laws suffered a series of weakening revisions. Between the expiration of New York City's rent and eviction regulations in June of that year and the ratification of the Rent Regulation Reform Act four days later, the legislature agreed to a laundry list of provisions attacking rent regulations, including minimum 20 percent vacancy increases on all apartments, permanent deregulation of empty apartments reaching $2000 a month, and deprivation of the right of low-income tenants to be heard in housing court when threatened with eviction under the so-called "rent deposit" law.

The result has been the intensification of New York City's already impossible housing shortage, and now even the middle class cannot find affordable housing.

If, as was indicated in McKee's letter, Goodman's excuse is that he challenges the leadership in "closed-door party conferences" (which can't be verified), it is obviously not strenuously enough to result in his being fired as Majority Leader Joe Bruno's deputy leader, a fate that befell Goodman's analogue in the state assembly, Michael Bragman, following a failed coup attempt against Speaker Sheldon Silver. This defense doesn't work. The Republican Party, of which Goodman is a major leader, continues to do the bidding of the real estate industry when it comes to rent regulation.

In a year when control of the state senate is up for grabs for the first time in a generation, and with redistricting looming, followed by the expiration of the rent laws again in 2003, a vote for Roy Goodman is a vote for Joe Bruno.

Kenny Schaeffer
Vice Chair
Metropolitan Council on Housing


I would like to register the enormous sense of disappointment that I felt upon reading the Fall Arts Preview [September 12]. As I browsed through the fine (but safe) jazz picks, and later, through the classical and rock choices, I began to wonder where the representatives of that ambiguous, multifaceted, vibrant, and (sometimes) annoying music that the listening fringe calls "Downtown" (or sometimes just "new") music would be found.

Surprise! They were nowhere! This music has been a part of the fabric of New York cultural life for over 20 years. Although it is created in places as far away as Tokyo, London, Amsterdam, Chicago, and the Bay Area, its growth and development have been inextricably connected with New York. Don't you think that music that is represented by such vital musicians as John Zorn, Elliot Sharp, Dave Douglas, Arto Lindsay, Susie Ibarra, Matthew Shipp, Ikue Mori, DJ Olive, Henry Threadgill, and Han Bennink (just to name 10 who have gigs in New York this month) deserves mention? Not just as some lunatic fringe offshoot of other genres, but in its own right. If not now, when? And if not here, where?  

Anthony Coleman

Music editor Chuck Eddy replies: Had the Knitting Factory and Tonic (which were contacted repeatedly) released autumn schedules on time, such Downtown gigs might well have been recommended in the Fall Arts Preview. Kyle Gann writes regularly about experimental "new music" in the Voice, and shows by the artists Coleman mentions are plugged frequently in the weekly Voice Choices.

Supreme Ironies

In "It's the Supreme Court, Stupid" [September 5], Ginger Adams Otis suggests that Democrats are superior to Republicans at selecting pro-choice judges. She says nothing about liberal justice John Paul Stevens, who was appointed by Gerald Ford; moderate justice Sandra Day O'Connor, who was appointed by Ronald Reagan; and moderate Justice David Souter, who was appointed by George Bush. For the record, Nixon appointee Harry Blackmun wrote the Roe v. Wade decision, while justice William Brennan, who voted with the majority on Roe v. Wade, was appointed by Eisenhower. One of the two dissenting justices, Byron White, was a John F. Kennedy appointee.

A couple of further ironies are that when Al Gore was a legislator, he voted against pro-choice measures, and a recent New York Times article indicated that George W. Bush has been selecting moderate judges in Texas.

Behrouz Vafa

Benny And The Jets

Re Peter Noel's article "The Shame of Mosque No. 7" [September 12]: As a former quarterback with the New York Jets (I backed up Broadway Joe Namath in 1974-75), I know a bit about airing one's dirty linen in public, especially as it relates to the shenanigans of professional athletes.

It's a sad day when any organization must face the frailties of one of its leaders. However, the sex-harassment suit against Nation of Islam minister Benjamin Muhammad should in no way disparage the intent of the Million Family March in Washington, D.C.I am reminded of other religious organizations that underwent sex scandals and remaineffective.

Just because a man is a fallen leader, or has moral lapses, the work of his organization should not be faulted.

J.J. Jones
Tacoma, Washington

Cutting Edge

Lynn Yaeger's piece set in 2004 reflecting on 2000 was great [Elements of Style, September 12]. Not only is she the smartest fashion commentator in the universe, she's clever too! This creepy retro-Reagan trend in fashion toward "sophistication" is as scary as Bush's shadow on the White House steps! It isn't even campy the way an episode of Dynasty is. It's more like prerevolutionary France. To that I say: "Get out the guillotines!"

Alex Segade
Los Angeles, California

'Outing' Transsexuals

Thanks to Tristan Taormino for shedding light on the exclusion of certain types of womyn at the Michigan Womyn's Music Festival [Pucker Up, September 19]. The time when it wasn't cool to be butch, femme, s/m, or transsexual is past. It's a new millennium, and that should be about change and acceptance of all forms of self-expression and sexuality.

Tamara Washington

Compromising Positions

After wading through 20-plus pages of "love for sale" ads in the September 5 Voice, I found the article "Objects of the Game" by Joanna Cagan. How gallingly disingenuous! You can preach all you want to us poor, unenlightened males about the audacity of making women athletes sex objects, but such juxtapositioning is a gross insult to my intelligence.

Thomas M. Bodenberg

Libertarian Links

In James Ridgeway's September 12 Mondo Washington column, the first item, about GOP plans for a massive tax cut, and the second item, about the anomaly of rising incomes and rising debt, could have been better connected. The rising incomes of Americans are very real. This is what has led to the huge "surplus" that Bush wants to give back. Unfortunately, for every $1 more we earn, the tax burden is 43 cents due to Social Security and bracket creep.

While most Americans do not seem to want a tax cut, it is probably the only way to get the Washington inside crowd to fix the vast Ponzi scheme called Social Security. For 30 years, payroll taxes have been used to cover huge operating deficits. If Congress is forced to fund current expenditures with current revenues, and to honestly deal with Medicare and Social Security, we might have a bright future.

Frank Murray
Shaftsbury, Vermont

Ukraine, You Saw, You Conquered

It is a pity that Robert Sietsema misled readers about the national identity of Cafe Glechik in his otherwise excellent Counter Culture review [September 19]. Although Sietsema acknowledged that Glechik has "a penchant for Ukrainian and Central Asian dishes," every single detail there from the name to the interior to the menu (with one exception, pelemeni) is screaming "Ukrainian" —not Russian—to me.  

It is a pity because such a review leaves readers unaware of the wealth of Slavic cultures (mostly) unknown to them which coexist with the universally recognized Russian culture.

It is a double pity because this further contributes to the widespread American ignorance of anything but Russia when it comes to the former Soviet nations. And they are quite different—and not always to the favor of Russia, as Sietsema seems to have noticed by comparing the regular Russian-style Brighton eateries to the Glechik—aren't they?

Vladyslav Dubenko

Peter the Great

Peter Noel's piece on the Brooklyn judge scandal ["Justice for Sale," August 29] was one of the most illuminating stories I've read on city politics in a long time. Noel is a New York City treasure.

Bob Fitch

Rock Saltz

I'd like to thank the Voice for including a quality critic like Jerry Saltz. It's always a pleasure to read his column as it translates its targeted subject with acuteness and depth, while avoiding dryness. In a way it is like a voice that Mr. Saltz has downloaded from the milieu of rock journalism.

David Twidle


In the Fall Arts Preview (September 12), a listing for "Ted Berrigan's Sonnets," a November 15 tribute to the late poet, stated that Berrigan would be reading from his own work. The Voice regrets the error.

Sponsor Content


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >