In "The Trojan Elephant" [September 14], Richard Goldstein portrays Log Cabin Republicans as lacking in social conscience. He is sadly misinformed.
I spent a year teaching math in the Chicago Public Schools. On their first day of high school, most of my students were unable to add whole numbers. To make matters worse, administrators told me that gross student misbehavior was merely "creative noise."
Gay people have a huge stake in making sure our schools work. Educated people understand the true meaning of diversity. Uneducated people call us "faggot." Yet despite obvious failure, the Democrats, as embodied by President Clinton, point to Chicago as a model of school reform. Democrats claim superiority to Republicans on issues like the Employment Non- Discrimination Act and hate-crime laws. Yet 30 years of Democratic Congresses failed to secure passage for these laws.
Never mind that gay people rarely face the kind of discrimination that other minorities have faced, and that strict enforcement of current laws would serve us as well as hate-crime laws. Democrats are lousy on the critical issue of education and effective on issues that matter little, like ENDA and hate crimes.
Republicans like Governor Bush, on the other hand, speak of the "soft bigotry of low expectations." After the hell I endured in the public schools, this speaks to me. I have a strong social conscience that cannot be bullied by the empty policies of the Democrat left. Now ask me why I'm a Log Cabin Republican.
Charlie Mehler, Former President
Log Cabin Republicans/Chicago
Richard Goldstein replies: Democrats in Washington and Albany have voted overwhelmingly for antidiscrimination laws, while Republicans have consistently blocked them. As for this writer: he's oblivious to the reality of job discrimination against gays, and he doesn't see the need for hate-crime laws. If you side with gay conservatives, this is what you'll get: a smile from the "educated" and a cold shoulder to oppression.
Hats off to Richard Goldstein, who has it exactly right about the new "gay friendliness" of the Republican Party.
Here's what gay Republicans should do: write in former Massachusetts governor Bill Weld and Los Angeles mayor Richard Riordan in the primaries to show the party the kind of candidates they could support. And then vote and work for Al Gore or Bill Bradley on election day.
The writer is the treasurer of the Democratic National Committee
The 'Blot' Thickens
When I saw the September 14 Voice with the headline "NYU: A Blot on the Village" emblazoned on the cover, I felt an immediate urge to respond that the university adds greatly to the economic and cultural health of the community and that it's not all about money. As a graduate student at NYU, I know that the young adults who enroll at school year after year contribute tremendously to the life of the Village. In short, your cover message came across as overblown and intolerant.
As for Lenora Todaro's article, there were numerous inconsistencies in her argument, but one glaring and overarching problem. It doesn't make much sense to defend the Village, a highly eclectic community, by making what amounts to a call for conformity.
On the other hand, NYU can hardly be considered just one more kooky neighbor, and it is reasonable to ask at what point the collective will of a community ought to take precedence over private privilege (assuming the will of the entire community is known). After he had refused interview requests by the Voice, NYU spokesman John Beckman entered the fray in the Washington Square News on September 20, calling Todaro's article "nothing more than an unbalanced, personal screed, the impact of which is somewhere between laughable and irrelevant." The arrogant tone of this quip makes one wonder whether Beckman has similar sentiments toward valid community concerns raised by Todaro, PR efforts notwithstanding.
Lenora Todaro's cover article on NYU was ridiculous. Is the Voice only asking that NYU design better-looking buildings? The real issue is how NYU is perpetuating the systematic segregation that has bulldozed minorities and women out of economic opportunities on its construction sites.
Workers from these communities black, Latino, and Asian have been fighting with students and community groups since 1997 to hold NYU responsible for sponsoring this racism. The question I have is: how can a rich, cultured educational institution that takes pride in being open and liberal say that it is not responsible for the blatant racism that workers meet when they attempt to get work on construction sites that are owned by NYU? Obviously, this was not a question that the Voice was contemplating in its ivory tower.
National Mobilization Against Sweatshops
Lenora Todaro replies: I argued against monotony (a.k.a. conformity) and for a harmonious streetscape in which architectural styles are in relationship to one another. The Kimmel Center would not make the neighborhood more "eclectic" in any distinctive way. Mr. Eng addresses a manner in which NYU's economic and intellectual might is used, one of many issues involved in its relationship with the city. I hardly think design is an ivory tower concern, however, as it affects everything from workers' rights and potential environmental hazards to psychological ease or unease on our streets. Try telling the people in the horrific housing projects in East New York that design doesn't matter. Washington Square and 14th Street belong to all the people of New York, including those Mr. Eng is fighting for, and it would be a shame if Mr. Eng didn't see the threats to their public spaces as "real."
Rally For Irish Editor
A rally in support of Ed Moloney, an Irish editor who is facing jail for refusing to surrender his notes and sources for an investigative article he wrote about alleged state collusion in the 1989 murder of Belfast human rights lawyer Pat Finucane, will be held at 3 p.m. on October 2 outside the British Consulate, 845 Third Avenue.
Letters should be brief, and phone numbers must be included. All letters are subject to editing for clarity, legal, and space considerations. Send mail to: Letters to the Editor, The Village Voice, 36 Cooper Square, New York, NY 10003. Or fax to 212-475-8944 or e-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org. E-mail letters must include phone numbers.
The Village Voice (ISSN US00426180) is published weekly (Wednesday) by VV Publishing Corporation, 36 Cooper Square, New York, NY 10003. Printed in U.S.A. Member Audit Bureau of Circulation. Newsstand price: Free in all new york boroughs, $1.25 in surrounding New York metropolitan area. Other locations $2. Subscription price $79 per year; foreign $114 per year. call 1-800-875-2997. The Village Voice is not responsible for loss or damage of original photographs in any format. Please do not send originals. Periodicals postage paid at NY, NY, and at additional mailing entries. Postmaster: Send address changes to The Village Voice, P.O. Box 3000, Denville, NJ 07834. Other mail: The Village Voice, 36 Cooper Square, NY, NY 10003. Back issues are available for the last two years, by written request only to Back Issue Dept.; $5 per copy. Free issues of The Village Voice are limited to one copy per reader, and may be distributed only by authorized distributors, retailers and outlets.
Get the This Week's Top Stories Newsletter
Every week we collect the latest news, music and arts stories — along with film and food reviews and the best things to do this week — so that you’ll never miss Village Voice's biggest stories.
- Breaking: Crane Collapses in Lower Manhattan, One Reported Dead
Wed., Feb. 10, 6:30pm
Wed., Feb. 10, 7:30pm
Thu., Feb. 11, 7:00pm
Fri., Feb. 12, 7:00pm
- Left-Wing Jewish Groups Claim Responsibility for Fake 'New York Times'
- Father of New York's Medical Marijuana Program Wants More Companies Licensed to Grow...