NYPD Detective Who Shot Unarmed Guardsman Claims Shooting Was Justified -- He Was Scared

Here's what we know about last week's officer-involved shooting that left an unarmed National Guardsman dead: there were two police vans full of cops who pulled over reservist Noel Polanco. He had no weapon at the time of the shooting, and witnesses say he had his hands on the steering wheel the entire time.

Additionally, two witnesses -- one of whom is an NYPD officer who claims she was sleeping in the back of Polanco's car at the time of the shooting -- say that immediately after the shooting, officers at the scene told them "your friend shot himself."

Despite the small army of cops on the scene, and the fact that Polanco had no visible weapon -- or any weapon at all, it turns out -- the NYPD detective who fatally shot him, 14-year NYPD veteran Hassan Hamdy, claims he feared for his life; he says he was justified in shooting Polanco and is "eager" to tell his side of the story.

Yesterday, NYPD Commissioner Ray Kelly said a grand jury probe of the shooting probably is necessary, and Queens District Attorney Richard Brown announced last week that his office is investigating the incident.

"We'll cooperate with the grand jury and the detective is looking forward to relating his version of events," Hamdy's attorney, Philip Karasyk, told CBS 2.

He goes on to say that Hamdy "felt threatened and was left with no other alternative other than the actions that he took."

According to witness Diane DeFerrari, who was sitting in the passenger seat of Polanco's car when Hamdi fired the fatal shot, the actions taken by police included several NYPD officers -- including Hamdy -- jumping out of a van with their rifles drawn when Polanco pulled over to the side of the road after weaving through traffic, angering the officers

She says that as the officers ordered Polanco to put his hands up, Hamdy shot him in the torso.

"There was no time to put your hands up at all. They shot in front of my face," DeFerrari tells the NY Post. "Had I moved an inch, it would probably have been me.''

She maintains that Polanco's hands stayed on the steering wheel the entire time, despite claims by police that he reached under the seat.

DeFerrari describes the incident as an act of police "road rage" -- she says the officers in the two vans, which she claims were unmarked, were mad when Polanco cut them off.

"They tried to run us off the road," DeFerrari said yesterday. "They [police] were shouting obscenities and the driver was sticking his middle finger out at us," she continued. "Noel sped up to get away from the car. There were no sirens, just lights. I told Noel to stop the car, but we caught a clearing and took off."

Then, she says, after Polanco pulled over, several NYPD officers jumped out of the van -- guns drawn -- and Hamdy shot Polanco as his hands were on the wheel in plain sight.

But according to Hamdy, he was justified in shooting the unarmed soldier -- he was scared.

Sponsor Content


All-access pass to the top stories, events and offers around town.

  • Top Stories


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >