Out of the Ashes
What was widely viewed as Rudy Giuliani's finest hour has become his worst.
It now appears that, in between the mayor's periodic announcements of the death toll, he was busily planning his own resurrection. His party hijacked the presidency last December, as Clarence Thomas's eulogy for Barbara Olson, the wife of the man who argued Bush's case before the Supreme Court, reminded us. Now it appears prepared to hijack the mayoralty if it can, aided by the Conservative Party, Democratic elements of the City Council, and an inventive interpretation of the term limits law. If this Giuliani campaign stalls, it will only be due to insurmountable legal obstacles, not any self-restraint or democratic civility on his part.
Michael Long, the ironfisted head of the state's Conservative Party, told the Voice that he is "willing to talk to Rudy" about giving him the party's ballot line in November, a line he never ran on in the past. Long has rebuffed prior Giuliani efforts to get his party's endorsement because the mayor has also sought the Liberal line. But Alan Hevesi already has that line and cannot legally give it up. As Long explained it, the only way a party can change candidates this late in an election year is by nominating their mayoral designee for a judgeship, and Hevesi "is not a lawyer."
The current Conservative designee, Terry Gray, is an attorney, and apparently willing to withdraw. Asked if Long expected Giuliani to seek a third term, Long said, "All signs are starting to look that way." Though it was his party that pushed the city's term-limits referendum through, Long said that "in times of war" he "would not be inflexible," suggesting that the City Council "would have to give consideration to changing the law."
In fact, Deputy Mayor Joe Lhota and others tried to round up council votes to overturn term limits on Wednesday and Thursday, right before the Friday special session. The New York Post ran an editorial urging repeal for all city offices, including the council, on page 52 Friday morninga clear message from the mayor. Councilmembers who'd supported the repeal attempt early this year were calledwith one, Queens Councilwoman Juanita Watkins, offered a city sheriff's car by Lhota's office to take her to the session.
East Harlem councilman Bill Perkins told the Voice that "someone on the mayor's staff" called him to ask if he'd support a repeal bill, and he said he wouldn't. Three other members, Herb Berman, Walter McCaffrey, and John Sabini, told the Voice they'd "heard about it" or had been contacted, but declined to get more specific. McCaffrey, who is wired into the council leadership, said that by Friday afternoon, the push to do it "had lost its momentum."
Stan Michels, the respected Washington Heights councilman who'd spearheaded a repeal drive earlier this year, was also contacted, but says he would not support a bill now because he questioned "the constitutionality of the timing," as did Perkins, Margarita Lopez, and others who once backed repeal. Council Speaker Peter Vallone, who marshaled the votes to kill Michels's bill in March, told reporters at a late-Monday press conference that he'd "always opposed" the repeal and still did so. Since it will clearly be impossible to eliminate term limits for councilmembers after Tuesday's primary, it's extremely unlikely that an overwhelmingly Democratic council would vote to repeal them just for Giuliani at that point.
That's why Giuliani forces are said to be studying an end run around term limits, which are part of the city charter and restrict the mayor to serving two "consecutive, full terms." The strategy is for the mayor to resign before his term is up this year, thus making himself eligible for another term. (And Mark Green, mayor for two months.) The question is whether he will have to resign before the election on November 6, because state laws seem to require that a candidate for public office be eligible to serve the day he is elected.
How such a gimmick will affect voters may be giving the mayor pause, uncertain that even with his enormous surge in popularity, he can pull it off. George Herbert Bush's 90 percent popularity ratings after the Gulf War evaporated within months. That may explain Giuliani's Monday equivocationwhen his deputies inaccurately predicted in the Times and Daily News that he would announce later that day that he was seeking another term.
The international praise for Giuliani has revolved around his calming press conference performances; no one points to any action he's taken or decision he's made. But his Monday performancethe day before critical primaries that should determine the future of the city he says he loveswas an exercise in megalomania. After recounting the heroism of a dead fireman whose funeral he was heading to and telling the families of the missing how they could get death certificates, he had to be reminded by the Shadowthe ever present mayoral hopeful Valloneto say something about the election.
He snorted about how he'd forgotten it.
This was a moment when any patriot would have reminded a broken city of the power of its franchise, when a call to the polls was as important a response to the attack as another call to arms, when a mayor suddenly able to inspire could have enlisted an army of citizens eager to demonstrate what separates us from the sultans of terror. Instead he said that "people decide on their own if they want to vote and don't want to vote," but that "if they want to vote, they should choose between and among the candidates there on the different lines."
He said he hadn't had "time to think about" his own possible candidacyone barred by a law he supported and passed in two public referendumsand that "as soon as I have time," he would talk to the people he trusts and make up his mind. He added that it "would make no sense to write my name in," reminding everyone that "the last time I checked" he wasn't a Democrat, suggesting that his no-write-in advice especially applied to the Democratic primary.
The comments were designed to position him for a possible run. A low turnout would enable him to do precisely what he did in 1997, when few Democrats voted in the mayoral primary between Ruth Messinger, Sal Albanese, and Reverend Al Sharpton. He said then that voters rejected them all "by just not showing up," adding that the reason "for the remarkably low turnout" was "the lack of a message of any of these candidates" about "the future of the city." He will not need to change a word to interpret a passive electorate as one still pining for him (no one noticed later in 1997 when he was reelected with the lowest total vote in a two-candidate mayoral race since 1925).
By discouraging write-ins, he averted any loss of momentum if he didn't actually get many. By particularly ridiculing Democratic write-ins, he helped his ally Vallone, who he may still hope will aid him on term limits, while simultaneously adding to the intended deflation of the total vote. If he winds up getting a lot of write-ins despite discouraging them, it will pump up his tabloid draft. So would beating Michael Bloomberg or preventing him from gaining 40 percent in the GOP primary.
In the end, Rudy may walk away from the opportunity he seems to be going out of his way now to create, just as he left the race against Hillary, implausibly citing prostate cancer as the only explanation. He has become so much the center of attention that more cameras initially gathered around him at Ground Zero last week than around the president of the United States. The Philadelphia Inquirer reported Friday that "W." selected Pennsylvania governor Tom Ridge for the Homeland Security post because "unlike Rudy Giuliani, Ridge is likely to be a solid team player who will not outshine or overshadow Bush." Rudy has apparently come to believe that the burst of flames that engulfed the towers and changed the nation also shone a spotlight on him.
Research assistance: Gregory Bensinger, Lisa Schneider, Lisa Williams, Catherine Worth
Get the This Week's Top Stories Newsletter
Every week we collect the latest news, music and arts stories — along with film and food reviews and the best things to do this week — so that you'll never miss Village Voice's biggest stories.