Spank the Bank
In March, student activists from across the country gathered in Florida for the Ruckus Societys second annual Alternative Spring Break Direct Action Training Camp. Instead of wet-T-shirt contests and drunken naked beach parties, campers role-played protest blockades, learned to rappel down buildings with huge banners in hand, and developed strategies for opposing one of the largest banks in the world Citigroup. Some of their complaints against the bank: predatory lending in U.S. inner cities, environmental devastation in the third world, and buying influence in Washington.
Backing up some of these charges, on March 6, the Federal Trade Commission sued Citigroup, alleging that one of its subsidiaries was engaged in predatory lending that victimized low-income borrowers by misleading them into loans with hidden costs. On April 11 students will launch a national day of coordinated actions against Citigroupcutting up credit cards, occupying branch offices, and pressuring college administrators to cancel exclusive contracts with the company. Several thousand students on over 50 campuses are expected to participate.
I was invited to the Ruckus camp as a guest trainer in guerrilla theater stunts. After a two-hour drive from the Tampa airport, our van pulled into a sprawling private campground filled with neat rows of snowbird trailer homes. We checked in at the Ruckus office (basically, an overhead tarp). A pool of cell phones was spread out on a folding table recharging like a litter of suckling pigs. I set up my tent in the dark and then strolled through the camp. Tents were strewn on patches of sand and grass. There was a medical tent and a vegan field kitchen that the next morning would serve up oatmeal and miso soup. A couple of local folks had come over with some beer, and we sat around talking, among us John Sellers, Ruckuss director. Founded in 1995, Ruckus trains environmental and human rights organizations in nonviolent civil disobedience. Behind us, looming through the moonlight, was a towering scaffold hung with rappelling ropes. So what are you guys protesting, anyway? Half a beat. Greed, said Sellers.
With 240,000 employees, assets in excess of $700 billion, and annual revenue of $112 billion, Citigroup is sixth on the Fortune 500 list. In 1998 Citibank and Travelers Insurance (which also includes the investment bank Salomon Smith Barney) merged to create North Americas largest financial institutionCitigroup. The merger violated certain provisions of the Depression-era Glass-Steagall Act, but Citigroup successfully lobbied the Fed for a two-year grace period in which to operate. Then the bank successfully lobbied Congress to repeal Glass-Steagall, which was replaced by the Financial Services Modernization Act. Since 1977 Citigroup has tallied $17 million in lobbying expenses, and over the last two years it has made $2 million in campaign contributions to both Democrats and Republicans. When new legislation that would formally legalize the merger ran into resistance, Citigroup enlisted the support of then secretary of the treasury Robert Rubin. In November 1999, the Financial Services Modernization Act was signed by President Clinton. One month earlier, Rubin had left the Clinton administration to become a cochairman of the newly legalized Citigroup. Rubins year 2000 bonus amounted to $45.3 million in stock, cash, and options.
Citigroup operates in over 100 countries and, according to the Rainforest Action Network (RAN), which is spearheading the campaign against it, has a hand in some of the most destructive development projects in the world. In Africa, Citigroup acted as chief financial adviser for the Chad/Cameroon Oil and Pipeline Project, which will cut through a rainforest and indigenous lands. In China, Citigroup underwrote bonds for the Three Gorges Dam, which will displace around 2 million people and destroy a rare river ecosystem.
Leah Johnson, Citigroups director of public affairs, disputes these claims. Citigroup is just a convenient target, she says. Weve been singled out not because of our record but because of our size and large customer base.
As a target, Citigroup is the logical heir apparent to the WTO, says Sellers, referring to the World Trade Organization, which brought the anticorporate movement into the streets of Seattle in November 1999. By targeting Citigroup, and trying to hold it accountable to socially and environmentally responsible guidelines, activists hope to have an impact on corporate business as usual across the globe. In 1999 RAN led a successful effort that pressured Home Depot to stop using old-growth timber. Soon after, a majority of the home-supply industry followed suit. The difficulty is that this isnt just another Home Depot, says Sellers. Were taking on the global financial juggernaut. Not just one product at one company. To win will require a fundamental restructuring of the global economy.
One immediate impact the campaign is seeking is an end to Citigroups alleged discriminatory lending practices. In November, Citigroup acquired Associates First Capital Corp., a Dallas-based consumer lending company that is now the focus of the FTCs predatory-lending suit. Federal regulators charge that Associates routinely deceived and lied to customers, tricking them into costly loan refinancing and making hundreds of millions of dollars of profit in the process.
Predatory lending is not unintentional, says Terra Lawson-Remer, a cofounder of Student Alliance to Reform Corporations (STARC) and recent graduate of Yale. It is a purposeful and strategic exploitation of poor people and people of color. STARC, which has been on the forefront of anti-sweatshop organizing on campuses, has also recently decided to put the heat on Citigroups alleged predatory-lending and redlining practices.
Redlining is the selective denial of banking services to certain communities. Long before they bought Associates, Citigroup was underserving minority neighborhoods, says Matthew Lee, of Inner City Press (ICP), a grassroots consumer and community group in the South Bronx, which has been fighting Citibank since 1992. There are 450,000 people living in the South Bronx, but there are only three consumer-accessible Citigroup branches here.
Last November during a hearing held by the New York State Banking Department on Citigroups proposed acquisition of Associates, an array of community groups spoke against the acquisition. But then later that afternoon, as Lee tells it, A gaggle of young, mostly white college students came to testify on the communitys behalf and about the environmental and social impacts of Citigroup projects all across the globe. This surprised the heck out of the regulators.
Citigroup, however, doesnt seem too concerned. When queried about the links between these diverse complaints, Johnson said, What links? Activists have come to identify unchecked corporate power as their common enemy. We shouldnt be drawing red lines around U.S. inner cities, says Patrick Reinsborough, grassroots coordinator for RAN. We should be drawing green lines around the worlds remaining forests. Johnson refused to comment on whether this multipronged campaign posed a threat to Citigroups image or its ability to appeal to new customers. Citigroup seeks to maintain constructive dialogue with RAN and other groups on relevant social and environmental issues, she said. We disagree with their pressure tactics, but we share common goals.
Companies like Citigroup have become so powerful that until you start asking questions about their global presence, community groups cant get their ear, Lee contends. Citigroup may not care what people in the South Bronx think, but theyve got to care about what white students think. Lawson-Remer agrees: As students, we have kinds of leverage that others dont. Besides cutting up Citi credit cards, STARC and the five other national student groups that cosponsored the Ruckus camp are working to divest university endowments of their Citigroup holdings and pressing for a jobs boycott by creatively disrupting Citigroup recruitment efforts on campuses.
Targeting Citi makes sense, says Dave Casey, a senior from Eastern Michigan University. He hadnt heard about the campaign until the Ruckus camp but is now planning to make it the focus of his campus activism. It puts a head on the enemy; it gives us an opportunity to take concrete local actions on campus. It also helps make connections because no matter what youre already working on, Citis probably involved in it.
The week in Florida ended with a campwide direct action role-play. Trainers stood in as police, campus officials, and reporters. A RAN staffer played Citigroups CEO, Sandy Weill, who was visiting the mock campus for a speaking event. In a scene of organized chaos reminiscent of recent antiglobalization protests, the campers put into play almost everything they had learned that week. One action team locked their arms through steel tubing to the chassis of a van, blocking the CEOs limousine from entering campus. Another team went to the auditorium, where three students locked themselves together on the stage with bicycle U-locks around their necks. Citigroup is profiting from racism, said one of the students hoarsely, as an aggressive newscaster from No Content News stuck a mic in his face. A third team scaled the walls of the administration building. A banner with Citis red umbrella and a slash through it fluttered high above the ground. Chants of Human need! Not corporate greed! filled the camp. The chants finally turned to cheers as the lead Ruckus trainer yelled out, OK. Stop! You guys won! It is unlikely that students will hear these words from Citigroup itself any time soon, but as Reinsborough says, This is just the beginning.
Other Useful Sites
Get the ICYMI: Today's Top Stories Newsletter
Catch up on the day's news and stay informed with our daily digest of the most popular news, music, food and arts stories in New York, delivered to your inbox.