The Word From on High
The Knicks and organized religion have collided like a couple of speeding cars in recent weeks, and the results haven't been pretty. But they sure are compelling. So imagine our surprise, and curious delight, when one of the main players in this latest Knick saga sat down right next to us at Sunday's playoff game against the Raptors. There was the controversial team pastor, John Love, far away from his usual complimentary courtside seats, with us in the upper press box near Madison Square Garden's blue seats. A few MSG security personnel had decided that the pastor's safety would be best served if he watched from this perch, and they assigned him a personal bodyguard just to make sure.
Love has served as the Knicks' voluntary chaplain for the past 12 years, but the last two weeks have definitely been the hardest. In the April 16 issue of New York magazine, head coach Jeff Van Gundy cited Love as a team distraction and object of his personal scorn. Then, as the pastor and his "God Squadders" on the team were recovering from that blow, The New York Times Magazine put out an article on Sunday that quoted Charlie Ward calling Jews "stubborn" and blaming them for Jesus's death and the modern-day persecution of Christians. Allan Houston backed up Ward in the Times piece with a Bible passage about Jews "spit[ting] in Jesus's face and hit[ting] him with their fists." Charges of religious insensitivity and outright anti-Semitism have rained down ever since: from the Anti-Defamation League, American Jewish Congress, and Simon Wiesenthal Center among others.
The fans chimed in as well on Sunday. When Ward entered the game early in the second quarter, they booed him, and booed him some more the first several times he touched the ball. "That's ridiculous," blurted Love. His bodyguard responded with a time-honored description of New York fans: "I love this crowd. They'll goad you one night, and make you a hero the next. They'll tell you exactly how they feel. They don't hide nothing." Said a resigned Love: "Tell me about it."
Before the game, MSG president Dave Checketts added himself and the Knicks organization to the list of those who found Ward's and Houston's statements "objectionable." Love responded that the quotes were only "objectionable because they appeared as isolated statements. Those statements were definitely taken out of context. I mean, how do we really know what happened and who said what? It just kills me knowing Charlie. He's really a lover of all people. He doesn't prejudge by their ethnicity or race, creed or color."
Love went on to defend the content of what Ward and Houston said: "The Bible is not a history book, but you cannot deny its historical accuracy." The pastor did say that the good book leaves room for some historical interpretation, and that the "sins of the entire world were responsible for putting Christ on the cross," not just the Jewish people. "To say that one particular group put him on the cross fails to recognize the source of the sins. But you cannot deny what the New Testament says."
Later in the game Ward hit two free throws and followed up by rattling the "What Would Jesus Do" bracelets on his wrists (in what is apparently this year's version of Larry Johnson's "Big L" gesture). At this point, the once hostile Knick gathering gave the point guard a round of applause.
"The crowd doesn't know if they should boo him, or cheer for him," Love's guard observed. To which the pastor replied: "I wish they would make up their minds."
Oh, God! Book II
Although you wouldn't know it from the uproar over Eric Konigsberg's surreal encounter with Charlie Ward and Allan "Hand Me My Palm Pilot" Houston, recounted in Sunday's Times Magazine, religious fanaticism and anti-Semitism have been a part of the pro-sports scene longer than jock itch.
In baseball alone, it's a line that runs from John "There's No Jewish Babe Ruth" McGraw in the '20s to Leo Durocher (who called his own pitcher, Ken Holtzman, a "kike") in the '60s to the San Diego Padres' John Birch Society starters Eric Show, Dave Dravecky, and Mark Thurmond in the '80s to Marge "Hitler Did Some Really Good Things, He Just Went Too Far" Schott in the '90s.
And then there's the sticks-and-stones side of the story. In 1919, when Ray Chapman was killed by a pitch thrown by Carl Mays, two of his teammates, Hall of Famer (and Freemason) Tris Speaker and catcher (and devout Catholic) Steve McNeill got into a brutal fistfight over which church would sanctify Chapman's burial, bloodying each other so completely that both missed his funeral. Hank Greenberg, who recalled being called "a Jew bastard and a kike and a sheenie" by rival bench jockeys, had his 1936 season (and almost his career) ended by Jake Powell, who broke his wrist on a routine play at first, while Indian star Al Rosen had pitchers throw at him in the '50s because of his religious persuasion, "but there's not a guy alive who ever saw me rub."
But sometimes irony is the best balm: Every Sunday the God-Squadders on the Los Angeles Dodgers hold their chapel in a conference room named for one of the team's legends: Sandy "Super-Jew" Koufax.
By the time you read this, the name George Herman Ruth may have been erased from the top of the baseball record books. Rickey Henderson, the 42-year-old outfielder for the San Diego Padres, stands only two free-passes away from the all-time walks record of 2062, the last major "counting" record still held by Ruth. Ruth had at one time virtually owned the record booktopping the lists of home runs, runs batted in, extra base hits, and strikeouts at the time of his retirement. (Ruth does still hold the career record for slugging percentage.) Next on Rickey Watch 2001: the all-time runs-scored record of 2245 (Rickey has 2179), held by another dead white guy, Ty Cobb. . . . Good to see Canadians clinging hard to their national pastime, no matter what the circumstances. During last weekend's demonstrations at the Summit of the Americas in Quebec, protesters used hockey sticks to slap away tear-gas canisters fired at them by police. . . . They say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. Well, we're practically red-faced after the huge compliment paid to Jockbeat in the April 23 issue of Sports Illustrated. The esteemed magazine's front-of-the-book Scorecard section followed our lead in a couple of areas in that edition, starting with what is probably the glossy's first skeptical take on the stadium-building boom. SI even quoted 1998 Voice sports journalist of the year, Andrew Zimbalist, in the item, which covered a subject that has long been a Jockbeat staple. A flip of the page reveals the Scorecard's "Style File," which bears a curious resemblance to "Uni Watch." So much so that it tackled a topic that we took on more than a year ago, in our April 18, 2000, issue: the San Diego Padres now-annual donning of camouflage-patterned jerseys and olive-green caps. Really, guys, we're honored. But we've long felt that way, considering the Scorecard section itself is merely a Jockbeat ripoff to begin with. . . . One last note on the Knicks-religion scandale: The American Jewish Congress has called on Katherine Harris (yes, that one) to remove Charlie Ward from his position as the official spokesman for Florida's "Born to Read" program because of his comments in the Times. Harris has yet to respond.
Contributors: Geoffrey Gray, Allen St. John, Ramona Debs, Peter Ephross
Sports Editor: Miles D. Seligman
Get the This Week's Top Stories Newsletter
Every week we collect the latest news, music and arts stories — along with film and food reviews and the best things to do this week — so that you'll never miss Village Voice's biggest stories.