The Bleak Future for NYC Students
Cathie Black was mocked out of the chancellorship, but what of the longtime failing educators who remain: her successor, Dennis Walcott, and the self-styled “Education Mayor,”Mike Bloomberg? I also include the fabled Joe Klein, now Rupert Murdoch’s education specialist.
For years, Klein and Bloomberg have been praised across the nation as model achievers of lasting education reform. Keep in mind that during those years, Dennis Walcott was deputy mayor for education.
Now the results of how they have blighted the futures of many of our public school students have been revealed in the current Department of Education high school reports. In “College Readiness Lacking”(New York Times, October 25), Fernanda Santos reports: “Only one in four students who enter high school in New York City are ready for college after four years.”She adds this obvious point by Bloomberg’s chief academic officer, Shael Polakow-Suransky: “There’s a huge change in life chances for kids who are successful in post-secondary education.”And much more of a life change for those who are left behind.
Not only the high school dropouts but also many of our graduates, too. In “Remedial class nightmare at CUNY”(New York Post, October 23), Susan Edelman adds this postlude to Joe Klein’s career: “A rising percentage of city public-school grads who go to CUNY—now 22.6 percent—need ‘triple remediation,’or catch-up classes in all three areas—reading, writing, and math—data obtained by the Post show.”
New York Islanders Playoff Round 2 Game C (If Necessary)
TicketsTue., May. 10, 12:00am
New York Islanders Playoff Round 3 Game A (If Necessary)
TicketsWed., May. 11, 12:00am
New York Islanders Playoff Round 3 Game B (If Necessary)
TicketsThu., May. 12, 12:00am
New York Islanders Playoff Round 3 Game C (If Necessary)
TicketsFri., May. 13, 12:00am
And nearly 80 percent of those who get into the city university not only have to take remediation classes but also “most languish there—never earning a college degree.”
So here we have the Education Mayor publicly glorying over what he insists is a significant rise in our students getting into college. Confronted now by the naked facts of what happens to many who do get through the door, Bloomberg first airily said: “College isn’t for everybody. There are other career paths.”
But to make a decent living in those other paths requires not only basic skills but also a command of critical thinking. Watch an electrician at work, as I have in grateful wonder recently when he got my record player working. Or a plumber or a locksmith.
Early in his time as chancellor, I asked Joel Klein if he intended to energize the fading vocational classes in the school system. He assured me he was working on it, and that was the last I heard about it.
Bloomberg, however, after reminding us about those “other career paths,”but giving no information on the state of the city vocational classes, went on to agree that “having a high school diploma is a very big deal. You can’t join the military, you can’t work for most city agencies without a diploma.”
But gee, have I forgotten about our high schools with an A rating? Surely these select students graduate in impressive numbers. However, dig this from Santos of the New York Times: “There were [in the new high schools report card] many exceptions among A schools. At It Takes a Village Academy in East Flatbush, more than 90 percent of students graduate in four years, but only 9 percent meet the college readiness criteria. At South Bronx Preparatory, the graduation rate also topped 90 percent, but the college-readiness rate was closer to 15 percent.”(Emphasis added.)
The Occupy Wall Street legions, railing against the gross class-based inequalities in our nation, should also camp out at the Department of Education—if they have any real-time, real-life changes to propose, unlike their present widely contagious hollow rhetoric.
Clearly, there are thousands of parents—and students—with concrete demands for essential and feasible ways of getting our school system to provide fulfilling futures for the great majority of public schools students—including the still neglected youngsters with special needs and disabilities, English language learners, and those with attention deficits and hearing and vision problems.
As our leading educators, are Dennis Walcott and the Education Mayor aware of the growing “whole child”approach to education? Dig this, gentlemen: “In any group of young people, you will find a range of physical, cognitive, social and emotional skills and abilities.
“No two students have the same strengths and challenges. . . . A whole child approach requires a strong belief that each child can learn, develop and be successful in a setting where the school and community ensure he or she is healthy, safe, engaged, supported, and challenged [by] supporting and developing the diverse needs of each student.”(wholechildeducation.org)
Standardized tests as a phony measure of student—and teacher—development and achievement bring to mind Albert Einstein’s being amazed that “imagination can survive our methods of formal schooling.”
It’s also amazing that critical thinking would survive our system, as well as joyous self-confidence as students become lifelong learners.
And if all this is too demanding of you, Chancellor Walcott, what are you at least doing to bring back civics classes—our tumultuous history of striving to be a self-governing free people? As the late Supreme Court Justice William Brennan put it to me: “How can we bring the Bill of Rights into the lives of students?”
This is happening in an increasing number of classrooms across the country. And I’ve done it—in a few fifth-grade and middle school classrooms over the years in this city—by telling them about the Bill of Rights and what it takes to keep those rights alive.
Meanwhile, coming back to the present bleakness of much of our school system, despite Joel Klein, Michael Bloomberg, and now Dennis Walcott, the “racial gap”in learning achievement continues. And as the city, state, and national economy shrivels, it will go on as there are more “layoffs,”to use the euphemism, not only of teachers but of lowest-paid support staff, including parent coordinators and school aides.
A New York Times October 3 headline lays it out: “School layoffs about to fall heaviest on the poorest and most struggling.”
There will be occasional slowdowns in the firings; but at one point as Santos of the Times reported: “Schools that serve large numbers of poor or struggling students are disproportionately affected, as are schools receiving federal money to improve results years after years of weak performance.”
I regularly read The New York Beacon newspaper (newyorkbeacon.net) for diverse black views and analysis of local, state, and national developments. In its October 6–12 issue, Juliet Kaye, reporting on impending layoffs, quoted Assemblyman William Scarborough (under the heading, “Pink slips for 800 school aides will impact communities of color”: “These layoffs threatened the most vulnerable in our city, many of them single mothers with children, and will have a devastating ripple effect on our economy. They must be rolled back.”
They are hardly likely to be rolled back under our incumbent mayor and Department of Education. When you vote for our next mayor, first ask yourself if he or she will be fundamentally different from Bloomberg and will insist that the Department of Education assure that our public school children actually have a future worth having.
But now, I kid you not, dig this invitation to a November 30 New York City dinner honoring, among other “Leaders in 21st Century Education,”none other than Joel Klein. It comes from the Center for Educational Innovation-Public Education Association.
See if you can stop cheering what Klein is being honored for: “He made the New York City School System a national and international model for success. . . . During his tenure, the city’s high school graduation rose to a record 65 percent. . . . Over the past decade, Joel Klein has been one of the most important forces in public education in our country.”
What planet are we on?
Get the This Week's Top Stories Newsletter
Every week we collect the latest news, music and arts stories — along with film and food reviews and the best things to do this week — so that you'll never miss Village Voice's biggest stories.