10 Naples-Style Margherita Pizzas Quiz: The Results
The Trianon, of Naples, Italy
This past Thursday, Fork in the Road put up a pizza quiz in which we offered photos of 10 margherita pies, all of them claiming to represent, in some way or another, the true pizza of Naples. Two of the pizzas were actually from Naples, and all of the others were from Brooklyn or Manhattan, except for one that came from San Francisco.
The quiz was certainly a tough one, since certain of the pizza parlors don't always produce a visually consistent product, while others were relatively obscure. Nevertheless, one participant (designated only as #10 on Google Docs, filling out the form on Thursday at 3:08 p.m.) guessed an amazing eight out of 10 right, and would have had a perfect score if not for mixing up the pies from Da Michele and Trianon, both authentic pies from Naples. You know who you are, #10, and we salute you!
Really, the pies look pretty similar, and general recognition was relatively low. The most recognized pie came from Co. (29 percent of respondents got it right) and Donatella (once again, 29 percent). The least recognized pies came from Barboncino, Saraghina, and Trianon (all 6 percent). This from a total of 17 respondents. Thanks all of you for participating.
In case you want to sample any of these pies, here are links for the ones in the city still open:
The identification of the pizzas follows
Mystery Pie 1 -- from Co. in Manhattan
Mystery Pie 2 -- from Kesté in Manhattan
Mystery Pie 3 -- from Trianon in Naples
Mystery Pie 4 -- from 900 Degrees, formerly of Manhattan
Mystery Pie 5 -- from Barboncino in Brooklyn
Mystery Pie 6 -- from Donatella Pizzeria in Manhattan
Mystery Pie 7 -- from Da Michele in Naples
Mystery Pie 8 -- from Saraghina in Brooklyn
Mystery Pie 9 -- from Pizza Napoletana in San Francisco
Mystery Pie 10 -- from Roberta's in Brooklyn
Like this post? Take a gander at the rest of our blog.
Want more Fork in the Road? Follow us on Facebook if you like pretty pictures of food.
Get the Food & Drink Newsletter
Our weekly guide to New York dining includes food news and reviews, as well as dining events and interviews with chefs and restaurant owners.