B & H Dairy's Soup and Grilled Cheese, Our Cheap Eat of the Day

B & H Dairy's Soup and Grilled Cheese, Our Cheap Eat of the Day

Soup and grilled cheese from B & H Dairy (127 Second Avenue, 212-505-8065), $8

Have a cheap lunch counter meal and support a piece of old New York.

With the shuttering of cheap eat institutions like Gray's Papaya, the Sixth Avenue location of which closed yesterday, comes an implicit lesson: When it comes to old New York, use it or lose it. That prompted us to stop by an East Village stalwart for lunch. B & H Dairy opened in the late 1930s, and it's been serving up lunch counter fare ever since. Most of the menu rings in under $10, which makes it a good place to duck into if you're craving old school macaroni and cheese, a tuna melt, or a knish. When we took our stool yesterday, we opted for our standby: the $8 grilled cheese and soup special. Neither is fancy; the grilled cheese is built on two slices of fat, fluffy challah, griddled golden brown and until the American cheese within is gooey, and it's served with a pair of dill pickle spears. B & H serves hot borscht, matzo ball soup, and vegetable soup in the winter, but we like the split pea, an earthy bowl of hearty stew.

B & H Dairy's Soup and Grilled Cheese, Our Cheap Eat of the Day

Hungry for more? See the Cheap Eat of the Day archives.

Restaurants open at a dizzying pace in New York City, and keeping up with what's hot takes some serious cash. If you -- like us -- need the occasional reprieve from a food-forward spending spree, you're likely always on the lookout for cheap eats of high quality. In this space each day, we'll highlight a tasty dish that rings in for less than $10, spotlighting places worth checking out when you'd like to get full while giving your wallet a break. Know of a great affordable bite? Email us.

Use Current Location

Related Location

B & H Dairy Restaurant

127 Second Ave.
New York, NY 10003



Sponsor Content


All-access pass to the top stories, events and offers around town.

  • Top Stories


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >