Dessert Dilemma: Pete Wells Acknowledges Similarities in Dishes at Blanca and Dirt Candy

Following up on his New York Times review of Blanca last week, Pete Wells points to a Twitter comment that calls out startling similarities between a dessert served by the restaurant's pastry chef Katy Peetz, and one offered by Amanda Cohen at Dirt Candy.

The controversy over the dishes isn't exactly surprising considering their components. At Blanca, Peetz began serving a watermelon radish gelato last September. Cohen's dessert, which was served from July to December of 2011, contained warm beignets and watermelon-radish sherbet. Additionally, both dishes were embellished with stick-in-your-teeth red gummy candies. However, the ever laid-back Cohen doesn't seem the least bit concerned with the situation. She told Wells, "Chefs, myself included, are constantly inspired by things they eat and dishes they read about."

We wonder how Cohen's super hero self would respond to such allegations.

Follow Fork in the Road on Twitter and Facebook and check out the rest of our food blog. Follow the writer on Twitter @malstuch.

Use Current Location

Related Locations


261 Moore St.
New York, NY 11206

Dirt Candy

86 Allen St.
New York, NY 10002


Sponsor Content


All-access pass to the top stories, events and offers around town.

  • Top Stories


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >