Five Great Affordable Tasting Menus in NYC

Contra's chicken
Contra's chicken
Bradley Hawks

Multi-course degustation journeys have proliferated in this city over the years, and while an hours-long feast can make for a unique dining experience, the expense can take a toll. Lately, some niche restaurants have offered a solution: four- to five-course menus that don't break the bank and change regularly, depending on what's fresh that day. Here are five great tasting menus in NYC, all $55 and under plus tax and tip.

Contra, 138 Orchard Street, 212-466-4633 $55 for five courses At this LES 44-seater from savvy gastronomes Jeremiah Stone and Fabian von Hauske, a restaurant signboard flickers in neon and alternative rock hums in the background. The duo offers a $55 five-course menu of thoughtful New American classics that echo dishes of their past. You might find crisp-skin chicken beautifully roasted and placed within the framework of chicken almondine with whole almonds, thin carrots, and a veil of seaweed jus. Or you might have a nuanced broccoli rabe balanced with a lemon confit and whole scallops and sharply garnished with rehydrated dried scallops. Dessert might be a combination of beet, yogurt, and hazelnut cremeux, a play that tastes like it could have been deconstructed from red-velvet pudding; that final course might be preceded by a bright tangerine granita with light-as-air popcorn mousse. No telling, since the menu changes every day.

Five Great Affordable Tasting Menus in NYC
Laura Shunk

Sushi Dojo, 110 First Avenue, 646-692-9398 $45 for 10 pieces of nigiri Everything in David Bouhadana's East Village temple of pristine edomae-style sushi screams upscale — except for the prices. $45 buys you an omakase experience that exceeds most others in the city. You'll eat two kinds of fatty tuna — otoro and chutoro — and creamy, sweet lobes of uni from Santa Barbara (or, if you'd like, from Maine or Hokkaido) on loosely-packed warm rice. Silvery skin-on kohada (seabream) glistens like armor; sweet amaebi (shrimp) is sweet and supple, deep orange Alaskan king salmon is clean and luxurious, and fatty saba or a satiny fluke might be dotted with monkfish liver. Extra pieces are modestly priced a la carte, so ask for more if you're still hungry.  

Gramercy Tavern, 42 East 20th Street, 212-477-0777 $48 for four courses at the tavern or bar Part of the thrill of dining at Gramercy Tavern's more casual area is knowing that a terrific four-course meal is half the price of the menu served in the adjacent room, and you'll still be privy to the faultless attention-to-detail that characterizes Danny Meyer's restaurants. Chef Michael Anthony turns out a list of seasonal, unpretentious classics. One dinner might feature Connecticut oysters as a prelude — smoky and luscious with roasted kale — and then traipse through a crisp salad of radicchio and sweet honeycomb apples, seared sea bass with salsa verde, meltingly tender duck breast, and a complex chocolate cake, as dense as Christmas pudding. One note: The tavern area only takes walk-ins, which means peak-time waits can take over an hour.

Aska, 90 Wythe Avenue, Brooklyn, 718-388-2969 $39 for three courses at the bar This small restaurant lurks within Kinfolk Studio's utilitarian space, which is a cafe by day. Fredrik Berselius puts out a minimalist Scandinavian board, taking staple ingredients and turning them into exquisite objets d'art. His quick menu at the walk-in-only bar features three dishes, although the complimentary breads — one a brittle crepe, the other a warm, nutty carraway loaf — served with local butter could be considered an additional course. The main event includes incredibly subtle briny Rhode-Island squid with sweet whole and pureed baby onions and a bracingly tender pork shank richly braised in its own jus and served with paper-thin lady apples and cabbage.

Five Great Affordable Tasting Menus in NYC

Barbone, 186 Avenue B, 212-254-6047 $39 for five-course pasta tasting menu Not to be confused with the glossy Carbone, this East Village eatery is a casual charmer, an homage to Rome with brick walls and antique sconces. Choose any five pastas from the regular or seasonal menu; we recommend comforting classics like linguine vongole — deeply accented with pancetta and whole garlic bulbs — the deceptively simple duck ravioli in a velvety red-wine reduction, or the garganelli in a thick, rosy sauce punctuated by heady wild boar.

Use Current Location

Related Locations


138 Orchard St.
New York, NY 10002


Gramercy Tavern

42 E. 20th St.
New York, NY 10003



90 Wythe Ave.
Brooklyn, NY 11211



Sponsor Content


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >