New York Neighborhood: Coney Island Restaurants Guide

Restaurants

4 Results

Neighborhood: Coney Island

Nathan's Famous Surf and Stillwell Ave. : Brooklyn, NY 11224 : 718-946-2202
The thin, crisp-skinned beef franks are legendary at this Coney Island stalwart––which may, hopefully, still be standing after everything else that's interesting in the vicinity has been pulled down and turned into condos and resort facilities. Second only to the franks in... More >>
Coney Island	American, Fast Food	Catering, Patio-Sidewalk Dining, Takeout	$

Totonno Pizzeria Napolitano 1524 Neptune Ave. : Brooklyn, NY 11224 : 718-372-8606
Located in the weed-choked neighborhood where Woody Guthrie lived out his final years, Totonno's sports the best fresh mozzarella of any pizzeria in town. That this cheese is a little soupy, making the pie damp, is fine with us. Just grab a fork! More >>
Coney Island	Pizza	Kid Friendly, Takeout, Wheelchair Accessible	$

Mixteco Grill 1609 Mermaid Ave. : Brooklyn, NY 11224 : 718-996-1601
The menu of this wildly diverse diner ? on a strip in Coney Island that a friend of ours described as “The new Bowery” ? extends to burgers, Italian pastas, egg breakfasts, wraps, club sandwiches, and even Salvadoran food, but its heart is in southern Mexico. Check out the chalkboard... More >>
Coney Island	Mexican	Takeout, Wheelchair Accessible	$

Shorefront West Indian-American Restaurant 2208 Surf Ave. : Brooklyn, NY 11224 : 718-946-6930
This Jamaican café and carryout on the far western end of Coney Island specializes in seafood, and the escovitch is superb: a choice of whole porgy or kingfish steak surrounded by masses of sweet pickled onions, served cold. But the smoking drum just outside the door signifies some... More >>
Coney Island	Jamaican		$