winners
essays
comments
ballots
search
previous p&j
2003
2002
2001
2000
1999
1998
ballots
Brian Wilson: #2 album
photo: Melinda Wilson
View Robert Christgau's
"Dean's List"
Select a critic and click "view ballot" to see an individual critic's votes.
Aaron, Charles
Abebe, Nitsuh
Abowitz, Richard
Adams, Jason
Adler, David
Agoston, Peter
Alden, Grant
Allred, Don
Aloi, Dan
Altman, Billy
Amorosi, A.D.
Anderman, Joan
Apicella, Vinnie
Appleford, Steve
Aquilante, Daniel
Ashare, Matt
Aswad, Jem
Augusto, Troy J.
Austerlitz, Saul
Azerrad, Michael
Babb, Pete
Baker, Soren
Baldwin, Chris
Ballots, Carry Over
Baraka, Rhonda
Barcella, Laura
Barthel, Michael
Bartlett, Andrew
Battaglia, Andy
Baty, Chris
Bayer, Jonah
Becker, Bart
Beets, Greg
Begrand, Adrien
Bemis, Alec Hanley
Beres, Derek
Berick, Mike
Berkery, Patrick
Berman, Stuart
Berman, Leslie
Berry, Max
Bessman, Jim
Beta, Andy
Birk, Nathan
Blackstock, Peter
Blanco, Alvin Aqua Boogie
Blardinelli, Jill
Blashill, Pat
Bledsoe, Wayne
Block, Brian
Bloom, Steve
Blount, James
Blumenfeld, Larry
Blush, Steven
Bosler, Shawn
Boughton, Steve
Bourne, Kay
Bowe, Brian
Brackett, Nathan
Bratton, David
Braxton, Charlie
Bream, Jon
Bregman, Adam
Breihan, Tom
Brew-Hammond, Nana
Brod, Doug
Brookins, Troy
Brooks, Caryn B.
Brown, Ethan
Browne, David
Brunner, Rob
Bruno, Franklin
Buoniconti, Dana
Burns, Todd
Burr, Ramiro
Burton, Brent
Bush, John
Calahan, Joel
Caligiuri, Jim
Caloudas, Constantine
Campbell, Chuck
Capobianco, Ken
Caramanica, Jon
Carioli, Carly
Carlin, Marcello
Carlson, Russell
Carmon, Irin
Carr, Eric
Carr, Daphne
Carruthers, Sean
Catucci, Nick
Cepeda, Raquel
Chan, Janna
Chandler, John
Chang, Jeff
Chean, Steven
Chen, Kris
Chennault, Samuel
Cherkis, Jason
Cheyney, Tom
Chinen, Nate
Choman, Al
Chonin, Neva
Christensen, Thor
Christgau, Robert
Chun, Gary
Chun, Kimberly
Chute, Hillary
Ciabattoni, Steve
Cibula, Matt
Cimicata, Mike
Cinquemani, Sal
Cisterna, Fred
Clark, Michael D.
Clark, Dove
Clifford, Dave
Cloutier, Cecile
Clover, Joshua
Clover, Sterling
Cohen, Jonathan
Cohen, Howard
Cohen, Jason
Comeau, Paul-Emile
Condran, Ed
Connell, Steve
Connelly, Jim
Considine, J.D.
Convey, Kevin R.
Cook, Dara
Cooper, Carol
Cooper, Kim
Cooper, Dennis
Corcoran, Clifford J.
Cornell, Rick
Cost, Jud
Cox, Paul
Crain, Zac
Cravens, Angela
Crazy Horse, Kandia
Cromelin, Richard
Cross, Charles R.
Cuda, Heidi Siegmund
Cummings, Raymond
Cunningham, John
Curtin, Michael
D'Angelo, Joe
D., Spence
Daddino, Michael
Dahlen, Chris
Dannemiller, Jerry
Danton, Eric
Darling, Cary
Dasein, Deena
Davidson, Josh
Davidson, Char
Davidson, Eric
Davis, Timothy
Day, Adrienne
Dayal, Geeta
DeCurtis, Anthony
Deeds, Michael
Dellio, Phil
DeLuca, Dan
DeRogatis, Jim
DeSantis, Carla
Deusner, Stephen M.
Devitt, Rachel
Dexter, Kerry
Deyampert, Rick
Diehl, Matt
DiMaggio, Daniel
DiMartino, Dave
Dixon, Glenn
Dolan, Jon
Dollar, Steve
Draper, Jimmy
Dreilinger, Danielle
Dreisinger, Baz
Drumming, Neil
du Browa, Corey
Dubbin, Rob
Durchholz, Daniel
Earles, Andrew Scott
Echlin, Hobey
Eddy, Chuck
Eden, Dawn
Edgerton, Robin
Edwards, Gavin
Edwards, Shawn
Eells, Josh
Elbogen, Eric
Eliscu, Jenny
Elliott, Cyndi
Ellison, Tim
Elrod, Norm
Elsasser, John
Elyse, Nicole
Emanuelli, Lola
Endelman, Michael
Engelhart, Tony
Epstein, Dan
Erickson, Steve
Erlewine, Stephen Thomas
Everhart, John
Evers, Derek
Eyre, Banning
Fairall, Jer
Farber, Jim
Farinella, David John
Feinberg, Ezra
Feliciano, Kristina
Fennessey, Sean
Ferguson, Dan
Ferguson, Jason
Fields, Gaylord
Fine, M.J.
Fine, Jason
Finn, Timothy
Finney, Tim
Fiore, Raymond
Fissure, Lalena
Fitzgerald, Trent
Fleischmann, Mark
Fletcher, Tony
Flores, Aurora
Foege, Alec
Forstneger, Steve
Fortunato, John
Fouratt, Jim
Fox Mayshark, Jesse
Freedberg, Michael
Freeman, Phil
Frere-Jones, Sasha
Fricke, David
Friedman, Ted
Friskics-Warren, Bill
Fritch, Matthew
Froehlich, Lee
Fuchs, Jesse
Fury, Jeanne
Gallippo, Eric
Gallo, Phil
Gallucci, Michael
Galtney, Smith
Gamboa, Glenn
Ganz, Caryn
Garrett, Jonathan
Geary, Rob
Geddie, Tom
Gehr, Richard
Gemelli, Zoe
Gensler, Andy
George, Nelson
George-Warren, Holly
Gil de Rubio, Dave
Gilman, Marc
Glazer, Joshua
Glowatsky, Pete
Goldberg, Michael Alan
Goldberg, Michael
Goldberg, Emily
Goldfein, Joshua
Golianopoulos, Thomas
Graff, Gary
Graham, Renee
Grandjean, Patricia
Grass, Randall
Green, Nick
Greenblatt, Jeff
Greenman, Ben
Greenwald, Andy
Grierson, Tim
Grose, Jessica
Gross, Joe
Gross, Jason
Grossweiner, Bob
Haag, Stephen
Hackney, Luke
Hadis, Diego
Hagan, Joe
Hall, Rashaun
Halpern, Ashlea
Handyside, Chris
Hannaham, James
Harrington, Joe
Harris, Keith
Harrison, Don
Harrison, Shane
Hart, Otis
Hart, Ron
Harvell, Jess
Harvilla, Rob
Haslett, Tim
Havranek, Carrie
Hawkins, Kristal
Hawks, Nathaniel
Heim, Joe
Henderson, Alex
Hermes, Will
Herrington, Chris
Hickey, Matt
Hicks, Dylan
Hignight, Heath
Hilburn, Robert
Hildebrand, Lee
Hill, Marc
Himes, Geoffrey
Hirsh, Marc
Hoard, Christian
Hochman, Steve
Hoffman, Ross
Hogan, Nathan
Hoinski, Michael
Holdship, Bill
Holley, Jr., Eugene
Holmes, Bill
Holter, Scott
Hooley, Danny
Hopkin, Kenyon
Hopkins, Tracy
Hopper, Jessica
Horowitz, Steve
Howard, Brian
Howe, Brian
Howe, Sean
Hsu, Hua
Hucker, Dave
Hughes, David
Huhn, Mary
Hull, Tom
Hunt, Sam
Hunter, James
Hurt, Edd
Hutlock, Todd
Inoue, Todd S.
Inskeep, Thomas
Jackson, Jeff
Jagernauth, Kevin
James, Robin
James, Falling
Jarnow, Jesse
Jarrett, Michael
Jasper, Kenji
Jenkins, Mark
Jenkins, Sacha
John, Kevin
John Hadley, Frank
Johnson, Robert
Johnson, Sherman
Johnson, Jeff
Johnson, Martin
Johnson, Lynne
Johnson, Charles
Johnson, Dean
Johnston, Maura
Junior, Chris M.
Juzwiak, Richard
Kane, Rich
Kasten, Roy
Katz, Larry
Kaufman, Spencer
Kay, Lawrence
Kaye, Robert
Kelley, Trevor
Kellman, Andy
Kellner, Amy
Kemp, Rob
Kenner, Rob
Kenny, Glenn
Kenward, Erik
Keyes, J. Edward
Killingsworth, Jason
Kilpatrick, Judson
Kim, Serena
King, Daniel
King, Larry
King, Jason
Kiviat, Steve
Klein, Joshua
Kleinsak, Michelle
Klinge, Steve
Klosterman, Chuck
Knopper, Steve
Kogan, Frank
Kortbein, Josh
Koslow, Jessica
Kot, Greg
Kristel, Todd
Krugman, Michael
Kun, Josh
Kuo, Ryan
Lach, Michael
Landa, Lara
Lane, Tom
Langhoff, Josh
Lanier, Brett
Las Vegas, Viva
Laskin, Tom
Lavin, Enrique
Lechner, Ernesto
Leger, Dimitry Elias
Leibrock, Rachel
LeMay, Matthew
Leone, Dominique
Lepage, Mark J.
Levy, Joe
Lewis, Catherine
Lewis, Randy
Lewis, John
Light, Alan
Lim, Dennis
Lindall, Anders Smith
Linden, Amy
Lindquist, Dave
Lipp, Dave
Lipp, Marty
Lipton, Michael
Loerzel, Robert
Loftus, Johnny
Lomax, John
Love, Josh
Lowe, Jaime
Lozaw, Tristram
Lukas, Paul
Lundy, Zeth
Lustig, Jay
Lynskey, Dorian
MacDonald, Cameron
Macias, Chris
MacNeil, Jason
Macnie, Jim
Maerz, Melissa
Magill, Tyler
Mamone, Jordan
Manning, Kara
Mao, Chairman Jefferson
Marcus, Greil
Marcus, Sara
Marek, Daniel
Margasak, Peter
Mariani, Anthony
Marino, Nick
Marks, Craig
Martin, Richard
Martin, Philip
Marvin, J Neo
Massimo, Rick
Masters, Marc
Matos, Michaelangelo
Matsumoto, Jon
Matteo, Steve
May, Thomas
May, Steve
Mayhew, Malcolm
Mazor, Barry
McCabe, Brett
McCall, Michael
McCombs, Joseph
McDonald, Glenn
McDonnell, Evelyn
McGonigal, Mike
McLeese, Don
McNeill, Darrell M.
McPartlin, John
Mehr, Bob
Menconi, David
Merritt, Kimberly
Mervis, Scott
Mettler, Mike
Meyer, Bill
Meyer, Jim
Meyer, Marianne
Meyn, Stacy
Micallef, Ken
Miccio, Anthony
Michaels, Rob
Michel, Sia
Midgett, Tim
Miles, Milo
Miller, Adam
Miller, Andrew
Miller, Eric T.
Mills, Fred
Milner, Greg
Milward, John
Mirkin, Steven
Mitchell, Rick
Mitchum, Rob
Mnookin, Seth
Modell, Josh
Moerder, Adam
Mohr, Tim
Molanphy, Chris
Moll, Susan
Montgomery, James
Mooallem, Stephen
Moon, Tom
Moore, David
Moreau, Kevin
Morgan, Jeffrey
Morris, Dave
Morse, Steve
Moser, Grant
Moskowitz, Jon
Moss, Corey
Mudrian, Albert
Mulcahy, Alex
Munson, Kyle
Murphy, Matthew
Murray, Sonia
Murray, Noel
Nash, Andrew
Neal, Chris
Nedelkoff, Robert
Nelson, Sean
Nelson, Chris
Nelson, Jessie
Nelson, Michael
Nichols, Natalie
Nicholson, Peter
Niimi, J.
Nolan, Robert
Norek, Josh
Norman, Tony
Norris, Chris
O'Connor, Rob
O'Connor, Christopher
O'Donnell, Kevin
O'Hare, Kevin
O'Neill, Bill
O'Neill, Brian
Ochs, Meredith
Orloff, Brian
Orlov, Piotr
Osbaum, Stacy
Ouellette, Dan
Overeem, Phillip
Padgett, Ethan
Paiva, Derek
Paoletta, Michael
Pappademas, Alex
Pareles, Jon
Parker, Erik
Parks, Andrew
Pastorek, Whitney
Patel, Joseph
Patrin, Nate
Paul, Franklin
Paul, George A.
Pelusi, Mike
Pemberton, Rollie
Pepper, Tracey
Peralta, Eyder
Perez, Rodrigo
Perlah, Jeff
Perpetua, Matthew
Perry, Jonathan
Peterson, Karla
Petreycik, Rick
Petros, George
Petrusich, Amanda
Pettigrew, Jason
Phares, Heather
Phillips, Brock
Phillips, Amy
Phipps, Keith
Pick, Steve
Pierson, Pat
Piotrowski, Daniel
Plagenhoef, Scott
Poet, J
Pogue, Bo
Point, Michael
Portnoy, Sean
Powers, Ann
Powers, Devon
Prato, Alison
Pratt, Tim
Price, Carey
Prince, David J.
Pryor, Tom
Puterbaugh, Parke
Pytlik, Mark
Rabid, Jack
Rabin, Nathan
Raftery, Brian M.
Raggett, Ned
Raihala, Ross
Randall, Mac
Rao, Shailesh S.
Raposa, David
Ratcliffe, Joshua Fahiym
Ray, Linda
Rayes, Ken
Reed, Bobby
Reesman, Bryan
Reeves, Mosi
Reighley, Kurt B.
Reynolds, Simon
Reynolds, Steve
Reynolds, Alex
Richardson, Mark
Richardson, Ken
Richardson, Derk
Riegel, Richard
Riemenschneider, Chris
Riley, Tim
Riley, Liz
Robbins, Ira
Roberge, Leonard
Robicheau, Paul
Robinson, Joseph
Robson, Britt
Rodgers, James
Rodgers, Lissa Townsend
Rodman, Sarah
Rogers, Matt
Romano, Will
Roseman, Ken
Rosen, Alison
Rosen, Jody
Rosen, Jody Beth
Rosen, Steve
Ross, Michael
Ross, Alex
Ross, Curtis
Rothman, Robin A.
Royko, David
Rubin, Mike
Rucker, Leland
Ruggieri, Melissa
Ruggiero, Bob
Ruhlmann, William
Ruttenberg, Jay
Ryan, Chris
Ryan, Matt
Sachs, Lloyd
Sanneh, Kelefa
Saunders, Mike
Schieber, Curtis
Schinder, Scott
Scholtes, Peter
Scholz, Erich
Schreiber, Ryan
Schroeder, Amy
Schwartz, Mara
Scoppa, Bud
Scott, Jon Jon
Scrudato, Ken
Sebastian, Matt
Segal, Dave
Semel, Paul
Semioli, Tom
Sendra, Tim
Seward, Scott
Seymour, Craig
Seymour, Gene
Shand, Billy
Shapiro, Jodi
Share, Don
Sheffield, Rob
Shepherd, Julianne
Sherburne, Philip
Sherlock, Dev
Sherr, Sara
Shimamoto, Ken
Shirley, David
Silva, Joe
Silver, Kate
Simels, Steve
Sinagra, Laura
Sinclair, Tom
Sisario, Ben
Skanse, Richard
Slaybaugh, Stephen
Smith, J. Eric
Smith, Rod
Smith, Craig
Smith, Ryan
Smith, Steve
Smith, George
Smith, Brian
Smucker, Tom
Snider, Eric
Snyder, David M.
Sokol, Brett
Sommereyns, Omar
Soto, Alfred
Soults, Franklin
Spitz, Marc
Sprague, David
Springer, P. Gregory
St. John, Allen
St. Leger, Elsie
Stancell, Steven
Station, Laurence
Stelfox, Dave
Sterzinger, Ann
Stewart, Allison
Stosuy, Brandon
Strachota, Dan
Stratton, Jeff
Strauss, D.
Strickler, Yancey
Strickman, Andrew
Stuart, Jonathan
Sullivan, James
Swaminathan, Nikhil
Switzer, Ken
Sylvester, Nick
Tai, James
Tamarkin, Jeff
Tangari, Joe
Tannenbaum, Rob
Tanzilo, Bobby
Tate, Greg
Tatum, Michael
Taylor, Ken
Taylor, J. R.
Tepper, Jeremy
Terrell, Tom
Terrell, Stephen W.
Terzian, Peter
Testa, Jim
Thee-O
Thompson, Stephen
Tompkins, Dave
Torres, Richard
Toure,
Townsend, Bob
Trakin, Roy
Tranfa, Tony
Tremayne, Jim
Trieschmann, Werner
Tsioulcas, Anastasia
Tucker, Ken
Turner, Brian
Tyrangiel, Josh
Tzou, Janet
Ubl, Sam
Valania, Jonathan
Van Dorston, A.S.
Van Vleck, Philip
Varela, Chuy
Varga, George
Vaziri, Aidin
Vettese, John
Vineyard, Jennifer
Vivinetto, Gina
Walsh, Jim
Walters, Barry
Wang, Oliver
Wang, Andy
Ware, J. Anthony
Warnick, Ron
Warren, Jamin
Washington, Rico "Superbizzee"
Weidenbaum, Marc
Weiner, Jonah
Weingarten, Christopher R.
Weisbard, Eric
Weisblott, Marc
Weissman, Dana
White, Armond
Whitney, Jon
Widner, Ellis
Wild, David
Wilder, Matthew
Williams, K. Leander
Williams, Dan
Willman, Chris
Wilmoth, Charlie
Wilson, Scott
Winters, Pamela Murray
Wojtowicz, John
Wolf, Mike
Wolff, Carlo
Wolgamott, L. Kent
Wolk, Douglas
Wood, Mikael
Woods, Scott
Worley, Gail
Wright, Rickey
Wuelfing, Howard
Wynn, Ron
Yatchisin, George
York, Will
Young, Jon
Zacharek, Stephanie
Zaleski, Annie
Zepezauer, Mark
Zimmerman, Shannon
Zupko, Sarah
Zwickel, Jonathan