As part of New York magazine’s current cover story on the glory of Gossip Girl, there’s a chart detailing the show’s various attractive stars and their human connections. Well, next to Chace Crawford, it says “Exes?!?”–yes, that’s the exact punctuation–with arrows pointing to two people. The first is, of course, Carrie Underwood who needs Jesus to take the wheel and guide her to a better union. And the second one? J.C. Chasez! Yes, they went there! Ain’t no lie, looks like Chace is bi bi bi.