Jockbeat: This Seals It – Kurt Warner Is The Best QB Ever


First, we’re going to start our post-Super Bowl coverage by telling you what nobody else would:  the Arizona Cardinals didn’t belong in the Super Bowl.  The Cardinals were not, as some pointed out, one of the weakest teams ever to make it to the Big Game, they were the weakest.

Over the course of the season, Arizona scored 427 points to their opponents’ 426, and they played in a division so bad that the rest of the teams in it won just 13 of 48 games against opponents in their conference. The Cardinals were thus able to sneak into the playoffs and host two playoff games, something their regular season performance didn’t really entitle them to. If the NFL had seeded their teams and dealt out the home games according to merit, the Cardinals almost certainly would not have made it to Tampa.

That said, the fact that the Cardinals were so perilously close to mediocrity made their Super Bowl performance against the Pittsburgh  Steelers in yesterday’s 27-23 loss even more courageous. If nothing else, the game proved once and for all that Kurt Warner is a Hall of  Famer.

We’ve mentioned Warner a couple times in this space during the postseason, but the lack of ink he got today after his amazing performance Sunday demands one more statement, and we’ll make it: Kurt Warner is the greatest quarterback in the game and, at his best, better than  Peyton Manning, Tom Brady or Brett Favre. His postseason stats alone leave the others in the dust  with an 8-3 record, not so gaudy as Brady’s 14-3, but Warner has thrown for as many TDs, 26, in 11 games as Brady has in 17, and Warner has averaged 8.4 yards per throw to Brady’s 6.6.

Kurt Warner was also the true MVP of yesterday’s Super Bowl. Not to take anything away from the trophy winner, Pittsburgh receiver Santonio Holmes (9 catches, 131 yards, one touchdown), but Holmes was no more a factor in the game than the Cardinals great wideout, Larry Fitzgerald (7 receptions, 127 yards, two TDs).  Warner was the man who made the game. Pittsburgh quarterback Ben Roethlisberger – 21 of 30 for 256 yards, one TD, one interception, and 8.5 yards a throw – but Warner was better, completing 31 of 43 for 377 yards, three TDs, and one interception with 8.8 yards per throw. Warner brought the Cards back from a 20-7 third quarter deficit, and he did it while throwing against a far tougher defense than Roethlisberger faced. And he did it all without the support of a rushing game (just 33 yards, all by Edgerrin James).


Archive Highlights