Gregory Moore–who brought you those wonderful Cary Grant/Randolph Scott montages–wants us to pose that question, and he’s generously provided hot shots of the nominees to help you vote.
So stop picking your nose and instead pick your favorite old-school hottie.
Oh, and please don’t add ones that aren’t listed here. That would be downright bratty.
The choices are plenty delectable enough, thank you.
My personal choice has always been and will always be Guy Madison. Couldn’t act his way out of a Glad bag, but who cared?