Defense Lawyers Whine that DA’s “Too Tough”

Can you believe this!? Defense attorneys are complaining that Manhattan DA Cy Vance — the guy whose job is, you know, to prosecute criminals — is “too tough!” The Daily News interviewed a bunch of defense attorneys (but also some prosecutors!), who are whining that Vance is clogging the city’s court system by refusing to hand out lenient plea deals and taking too many cases to trial. The gall!

One defense attorney told the News that “a lot of cases that should be settled are not getting settled,” speculating that maybe the DA’s office is refusing to plea bargain because they’re bored (the county has filed 4% fewer felony cases this year).

But then another anonymous lawyer suggested that prosecutors might just be stupidly stubborn, citing a “big-time drug case” where the the DA had a “weak” case and refused to offer a plea deal. (The defendant was apparently acquitted.)

The hard-line approach, along with Vance’s reported crackdown on serious misdemeanors and repeat offenses, has caused the number of courtroom trials to spike by a whopping 129 percent, which defense attorneys are complaining will jam the wheels of justice to a grinding halt.

But Vance seems pretty serious about having his cake and eating it, too. The News says he’s shuffled around top prosecutors’ duties to wade through the backlog of cases, causing a 10 percent drop in the number of cases that get dismissed. But at least the big guy isn’t afraid to get his hands a little dirty himself — in April, the New York Times even caught a rare glimpse of Manhattan’s top prosecutor in the courtroom.

More:Crime

Archive Highlights

From The Archives

The Big Bang Boom

The Rockets' Red Glare, Bombs Bursting in Air, and the World's Longest String-of Firecrackers. Taking Cover at the 18th Annual Pyrotechnic Convention

by Guy Trebay
Pride

Sylvester: Staying Alive

“For almost 20 years, Sylvester has been an icon of San Francisco nightlife: outrageous, bold, proud. Today, he is a symbol of a totally different San Francisco — a gay man struggling to stay alive”

by Barry Walters
The Culture

The Unbearable Whiteness of Publishing, Pt. 1

“For the first five years that I was writing for The New Yorker,” says a longtime contributor, “the closest I ever got to a person of color was a young white fact-checker with dreads.”

by James Ledbetter
From The Archives

BLACK LIKE WHO? Arguing With the Homeboys

“Given that black folks make art and market it within white supremacist capitalist patriarchy, none of us can ignore the reality that any black person who wants to create a product with mass crossover appeal must do some serious soul-searching”

by bell hooks
Theater

Genet, Mailer, & the New Paternalism

“The new paternalists really think, it seems, that their utterances of the oldest racial cliches are, somehow, a demonstration of their liberation from the hanky-panky of liberalism and God knows what else”

by Lorraine Hansberry
From The Archives

Milton Glaser at the Voice – Short Time, Big Impact

The design virtuoso, who died last week at age 91, brought the Voice's editorial look up to speed

by R.C. Baker

News & Politics

Defense Lawyers Whine that DA’s “Too Tough”

by Sergio Hernandez

Archive Highlights