Gabrielle Giffords’ Husband Heard She Was Dead; NPR Repents For False Reports


Mark E. Kelly, the astronaut husband of Rep. Gabrielle Giffords, who was shot in the head during Jared Loughner’s Arizona killing spree, heard unverified media reports that his wife died in the hospital after the shooting, he told ABC’s 20/20 last night. “And I just, you know, walked into the bathroom, and you know, broke down,” he said. Then he spoke on the phone to Giffords’ mother, who informed him that she was still fighting for her life. Her condition continues to improve. But NPR, who first reported Giffords’ death via “the Pima County Sheriff’s department and a congressional source,” gets a stern talking to from ombudsman Alicia Shepard for the “real, excruciating pain [the report] triggered.”

“Please tell them to stop reporting she is dead,” a family friend told an NPR correspondent over the phone that afternoon. “She is in surgery.”

NPR aired its incorrect report only once but then compounded the error by waiting until the next day to air a correction, accompanied by an apology from its executive editor, Dick Meyer.

On Jan. 13, managing editor David Sweeney sent an email to staff. Sweeney reminded them that reporting breaking news during a major event – such as a terrorist attack or a mass shooting – must be approved by a senior news manager. This extra layer of caution was not used in the Giffords’ case.

Of course, one wrong report can snowball, with Shepards acknowledging that reports of Giffords’ death were “repeated on, e-mail alerts, Twitter and picked up by other news organizations.” Thankfully, they were greatly exaggerated.

Video Captured ‘Calculated’ Gunman in Tucson [NYT]
How NPR’s Giffords Mistake Hurt The Families [NPR]

This article from the Village Voice Archive was posted on January 19, 2011

Archive Highlights