Fork in the Road’s Favorite Pizza in New York City


It’s time for Tuesday Toasts, our weekly feature highlighting the Fork in the Road team’s favorite versions of popular dishes and favorite spots in the city for a given activity. They might not be the best or the coolest or the newest, but instead represent the things and places that are near and dear to our hearts. Will the team have wildly diverging opinions, or do great minds think alike? There’s only one way to find out. Up this week: Our Favorite Pizza.

“Totonno’s.” –Chantal Martineau

“Love the old coal-oven places, and my fave is Totonno’s in Coney Island, with Patsy’s and John’s (original locations only) tied for second.” –Robert Sietsema

“Best Pizza. The grandma and veggie slices are my pizza Platonic ideal. I could eat that crust by the pound.” –Rebecca Marx

“I’ve been really into Best Pizza recently. But I get pizza delivery from Lil’ Frankie’s a lot because it’s near my house.” –Lauren Shockey

Have a tip or restaurant-related news? Send it to

And follow us on Twitter: @ForkintheRoadVV.