City Votes to Close 23 Public Schools, Parents Are Not Pleased


Last night, the Panel for Educational Policy voted to close or partially shutter 23 public schools, a record-setting decision that has many parents angry and upset. Nearly 2,000 angry moms and dads, joined by protesters from the Occupy movement, crowded into the Fort Greene auditorium where the vote was being held last night to demand an explanation. Most of the schools slated for closure are in Central Brooklyn, but the city also voted to shut down three in Manhattan. Of the 23 schools voted on, 18 will be shut down entirely, while the remaining five will lose some of their grades (and therefore, some funding).

The schools in question came under scrutiny for their low test scores and graduation rates. Many of them suffered under the burden of special-needs and poverty-stricken students, factors that can make it difficult for instructors to help students even when they are well-trained.

Mayor Bloomberg has long advocated completely shutting down failing public schools in order to re-open new ones in the same areas, a move that many have criticized as too little, too late. City Councilmember Jumaane Williams of Brooklyn said at the hearing, “The mayor has had 10 years and he’s failed.”

But Councilmember Byron Davis told PIX 11 after the vote, “Why would you want your kid to go to a school where only 50 to 60 percent graduate. Because they don’t know the system.”

The full list of school closures is as follows:


  • Middle School for the Arts, 790 East New York Avenue
  • PS 19 Roberto Clemente, 325 South 3rd Street
  • PS 22, 443 St. Marks Avenue
  • PS 161 The Crown, 330 Crown Street (middle grades only)
  • PS 298 Dr. Betty Shabazz, 85 Watkins Street (middle grades only)
  • Satellite Three Middle School, 170 Gates Avenue
  • Gen. D. Chappie James Elementary School of Science, 76 Riverdale Avenue
  • IS 296 Anna Gonzalez, 125 Covert Street
  • International Arts Business School, 600 Kingston Avenue
  • Brooklyn Collegiate, 2021 Bergen Street (middle grades only)
  • Frederick Douglass Academy IV Secondary School, 1014 Lafayette Avenue (middle grades only)
  • Academy of Business and Community Development, 141 Macon Street

The Bronx:

  • Academy for Scholarship and Entrepreneurship, 921 East 228th Street (middle grades only)
  • Aspire Preparatory Middle School, 2441 Wallace Avenue
  • Gateway School for Environmental Research and Technology, 1980 Lafayette Avenue
  • Samuel Gompers Career and Technical Education HS, 455 Southern Boulevard
  • Grace Dodge Career and Technical Education HS, 2474 Crotona Avenue
  • Jane Addams HS for Academic Careers, 900 Tinton Avenue


PS 215 Lucretia Mott, 535 Briar Place, Far Rockaway


  • Manhattan Theatre Lab HS, 122 Amsterdam Avenue
  • Washington Irving HS, 40 Irving Place
  • Legacy School for Integrated Studies, 34 W 14th St

Staten Island:

  • PS 14 Cornelius Vanderbilt, 100 Tompkins Avenue