The Best (and Cheapest) NYC Alt and Indie Comedy Shows This Week – 10/2/2013


It’s an all-nerd pick this week, as the city prepares to welcome New York Comic Con. We have all manner of geeked-out funny people for you, from rapping improv dorks and Merrie Melody fans, to Texan history enthusiasts and men who name stand-up albums after Founding Fathers of American Commerce. Grab your doctor’s note and get comfortable on the losers’ bench: here are the nerdiest comedy picks to date.

Wednesday, October 2nd

The Guest Room
Tandem Bar, 8:30 p.m. Free
The list of people with comedy albums named after Secretaries of the U.S. Treasury is short. But John Roy’s Alexander Hamilton is without doubt the best, and he headlines this debut Bushwick show at venerable neighborhood watering hole Tandem. Cheerful hosts Bob Palos and Ronnie Fleming also welcome top New York beard-owner Andy Sandford, alongside Koshin Egal and Chris Calogero.

Thursday, October 3rd

The Modern Philosophers
The Creek and the Cave, 9 p.m. Free
Leah Bonnema and Tim Warner, two of the funniest working comics in New York, host a relaxed monthly showcase interspersed with classic Merry Melodies and Hanna Barbera cartoons. Between acts, they dissect the life lessons imparted by the Gospels according to Daffy, Porky and those other Great Apostles of American Silliness, Tweety and Sylvester. An open vodka bar is also laid on for audience members from 8.30pm, saucing you up real good for your headliner, Daily Show alumnus Wyatt Cenac.

Friday, October 4th

Take It Personal
UCBeast, 9 p.m. $10
DJ Cipha Sounds from Hot 97 FM and Chappelle’s Show believes he has uncovered the ancient connection between hip-hop and Improv, and who are we to argue? This show features a surprise rap star sharing amazing true life stories and regular hip-hop shenanigans (Cristal, haters, beefs, etc.), inspiring the city’s best stage performers to create a fully improvised show on the spot.

Saturday, October 5th

See You In Hell
The Creek and the Cave, 8 p.m. Free
What if a comedy show was run by Satan? Doug Smith and Matt Wayne try to answer that question, putting up the best stand-ups in New York, and then attempting to ruin their performances with ever more ridiculous dares, stunts and derailments. Come for the jokes, stay for the abject humiliation. Joe Zimmerman, Matteo Lane, Peggy O’Leary and Noah Gardenschwartz will the subjects of infernal wrath.

Sunday, October 6th

Creaghead and Company
Union Hall, 8 p.m. $7
Making video tapes is the comedian’s equivalent of chefs publishing their recipes: they’ve tested a set of jokes to destruction, and found the perfect blend of beats and punches to delight a crowd. Time to commit them to digital perpetuity and begin the next round of sharpening new material. Tonight, three of the best young comic talents in he country each lay down a new 30 minute set: Mark Normand, Nick Turner, and Barry Rothbart (see above), combining to produce a stand out night of stand-up.

Monday, October 7th

UCB Chelsea, 8 p.m. $5
Ever wonder what a musical version of America’s origin would look like… if based on the rabidly conservative Texas Board of Education history textbook? Well, wonder no more! Watch and marvel as Jesus Christ helps build a nation that’s courageous, pious, and gun-crazy enough to give his precious Constitution to. But will the evil King Barack Hussein George III get in his way? There’s only one way to find out.

Tuesday, October 8th

404ing It: Breaking (Down) The Internet
UCBeast, 8 p.m. $5
You’re a nerd, right? Right. So come on down to UCB’s haven for you people: 404ing It. This week’s performance is dedicated to New York Comic Con, featuring the hosts of the Matt and Brett Love Comics podcast, Late Night with Jimmy Fallon writer Mike Drucker, and the Godfather of Nerd-core hip-hop MC Chris. Bring your inhaler: it’s going to get wheezy.