The Headless Horse Ban

Bill de Blasio's pledge to abolish horse-drawn carriages is running away from him

The Headless Horse Ban
Jesse Dittmar

Bill de Blasio started his mayorship with a promise to ban horse drawn carriages "immediately," vowing that he'd end the Central Park tradition his first week in office.

At a pre-inauguration press conference, he promised, "We are going to quickly and aggressively move to make horse carriges no longer a part of the landscape in New York City. They are not humane... it's over."

But four months later, that promise is falling apart. The carriage industry has launched an intense public relations campaign against the ban, one that seems to be working. The New York Times, the Daily News and the Post have all come out against the ban, and a recent poll showed weakening public support for the idea. A number of City Council members no longer seem sure they'll vote for the ban, even one who sponsored a similar ban bill last session.

Carriage driver Christina Hansen, left, and carriage owner and driver Stephen Malone pose with Malone’s horses at the Clinton Park stables.
Jesse Dittmar
Carriage driver Christina Hansen, left, and carriage owner and driver Stephen Malone pose with Malone’s horses at the Clinton Park stables.
Malone and Tyson pull a passenger
Jesse Dittmar
Malone and Tyson pull a passenger
The hack line at Central Park South
Jesse Dittmar
The hack line at Central Park South
Carriages at rest at the Clinton Park stables
Jesse Dittmar
Carriages at rest at the Clinton Park stables
“These horses have lives of deprivation and confinement,” says Friends of Animals’ Edita Birnkrant.
Jesse Dittmar
“These horses have lives of deprivation and confinement,” says Friends of Animals’ Edita Birnkrant.

As the fight drags on, it's getting nastier and weirder. Animal rights group NYCLASS, the main organization behind the ban, has thrown all of their time and money into an unrealistic, wildly expensive plan to replace the carriages with electric-powered vintage replica cars, an idea that virtually no one else supports.

On the other side, the carriage industry is getting support from an increasingly odd group of people, including Liam Neeson and a shadowy, Missouri-based lobbying group who advocate for the rights of animal owners to do whatever they want with their animals, and thinks it should be legal in the U.S. to slaughter horses for food.

Read the full story in this week's Village Voice.

 
My Voice Nation Help
3 comments
eero.iloniemi
eero.iloniemi

It's illegal to slaughter horses for food in America? Really?

Incredible!

rob035
rob035

How about rickshaws, pulled by animal-rights activists?

 
New York Concert Tickets
Loading...