Top

news

Stories

 

Stoning Women to Death

Coming soon to the United Nations: Iran's chief executioner of women

On . . . June 29, 2006, a court in the Islamic Republic of Iran sentenced Malak Ghorbany, a 34-year-old mother of two, to a brutal death by stoning after finding her guilty of adultery. . . . Two men who were found guilty of murder in the same court were only given jail sentences of six years. . . . The size of the stones used during the execution are required to be . . . not so large that they would kill a woman too quickly, nor so small that they would fail to cause serious injury or pain . — A letter, unanswered, to George W. Bush from John Whitehead, head of the Rutherford Institute, one of the nation's premier civil liberties organizations. The part about the stones is from Article 104 of the Iranian penal code.


Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, the president of Iran, has become an international celebrity, brandishing his nuclear program—and his yearning to wipe Israel off the face of the earth. He is visited by such personages as U.N. secretary-general Kofi Annan and Mike Wallace of 60 Minutes. In their conversations with him, neither has asked the swashbuckling leader about "honor killings" by the government of women charged with having committed "adultery."

As human rights lawyer Lily Mazahery, president of the Legal Rights Institute reports, "in 99 percent of these cases, the accused women have received no legal representation because, under the Shariah legal system, their testimony is at best worth only half the value of the testimony of men."

And there is no single executioner. These are mass murders by stone-throwing members of the community, having the kind of festive time common among American mass lynchers of blacks, when the murderers brought their children to join in the fun. In Iran too, kids are present to witness the sinners' redemption.

The capital crime of adultery, Mazahery has explained to World Net Daily, "includes [under Shariah law] any type of intimate relationship between a girl/woman and a man to whom she is not permanently or temporarily married. Such a relationship does not necessarily mean a sexual relationship.

"Further, charges of adultery are routinely issued to women/girls who have been raped—and they are sentenced to death." (Their unpardonable crime is to have been raped.)

During the continuous coverage in this country of Iran's nuclear threat and its crucial support of terrorists in Iraq and elsewhere in the Middle East, there has been scarcely any mention of this horrifying dimension of the culture of Iran: sangsar, the stoning to death of women.

Mazahery, the Persian American lawyer whose mission has long been to save Iranian women from this and other brutal treatment, tells me that sangsar, "dating back to the dark ages," was, for a time, suspended by the pre-revolutionary regime due to pressure from international human rights organizations, combined with protests from civilized persons around the world. But when the mullahs took over in the 1979 revolution, they brought back Shariah law, and when this president came to power, he reinstituted public stonings, as a "religious principle," against women.

As of this writing, President Ahmadinejad is on his way to address the United Nations in New York. There will be heavy press coverage. Will any reporter ask him about the stoning of women in his country—and the particular case of Malak Ghorbany? And while former "moderate" Iranian president Mohammad Khatami has been in the United States—lecturing at Harvard, among other prestigious venues—I know of no reporter who has asked him to discourse on the stoning of women under his successor.

Mazahery, who was recently invited by students and faculty to respond to Khatami at Harvard, has written and circulated an online petition, "Save Malak Ghorbany From Death by Public Stoning," addressed to Kofi Annan; the U.N.'s commissioner of human rights; and Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, leader of the Islamic Republic of Iran; as well as to the head of its judiciary, Ayatollah Mahmoud Shahroudi.

So far, there have been more than 11,000 signatories—from around the world, including this country, China, and most tellingly, Iran. For Iranians to sign took much courage. As Ali Afshari and Akbar Atri—founding members of Iranian Students for Democracy and Human Rights—revealed in the September 2–3 Wall Street Journal:

"Satellite dishes are being collected to cut off public access to the . . . news of the global community. Women's groups, labor organizations, and student groups are not permitted even the more peaceful acts of protest."

As a result, however, of growing international concern about Malak Ghorbany, partly from Mazahery's petition, the Islamic regime has stayed her execution until she gets a new trial. But as Mazahery points out, Iran has used this three-card-monte trick before. As she told World Net Daily: "It is quite possible the Islamic regime will schedule a rush sham trial and reissue the same sentence [and] even with a new trial, Ghorbany would still receive the same sentence or be sentenced to death by public hanging instead."

The pressure to save Malak Ghorbany must continue. The direct link to Malak's petition, where you can sign on, is petitiononline.com/Malak/petition.html. For related topics, and to link to videos of actual public stonings, click on savemalak.googlepages.com/home.

1 | 2 | Next Page >>
 
  • margaret 07/09/2010 5:59:00 PM

    The United States allowed Iran with no contest ( Susan Rice - Ambassador to the US - appointed by Obama did not even attend the vote) to become a member of the United Nations Commission on the Status of Women. Nobody denounced this and now look what continues to be a daily ritual for Iranians with these crimes against innocent women for showing an ankle or appearing suntanned. Though men are also stoned, they are only buried up to their waist. Women are buried up to their necks. It is stated that if they escape prior to death they shall be set free, but they are most often recaptured and shot/killed or reburied and the stoning continues. Family members including children are forced to watch. Great job USA in allowing and condoning these lunatics from Iran to translate the Quran to their liking ( no stoning is indicated as punishment - only lashings as if that wasn't bad enough) to continue this treatment of women of all ages by allowing them on the UN Council for women!!! Woo hoo!!! I guess Hillary is too busy planning Chelsea's lavish wedding to give any thought to this situation. And Obama? When is he going to stand up for America no less the women of Iran?

  • p.a.mohamed ameen 07/09/2010 3:35:00 PM

    Stoning to death as a punishment for adultery is NO WHERE spoken of in the Holy Quran. At one instance stoning was done to a Jew- that was based on the Jewish Holy Book. The Jews referred a case on fornication to Muhammad-the Messenger of God (pbuh). He asked them what punishment the Torah prescribed in case of adultery. The Jews tried first to conceal the fact that it was stoning to death, but the Jewish scholar living then ( Abd-Allah ibn Salam) admitted the existence of such a punishment and the guilty persons were dealt with as given in Torah ( Bukhari 61;25). The New Testament narrates a similar incident during the time of Jesus Christ(puh) I quote from John Chapter 8 Verses 3,4 and 5. Verse 3. Then the scribes and Pharisees brought to him (Jesus) a woman caught in adultery. And when they set her in the midst. Verse 4. They said to him, “Teacher, this woman was caught in adultery, in the VERY ACT. Verse 5. “Now Moses, in the law commanded us that such SHOULD BE STONED. But what do you say?” JOHN 8: 3-5 So you can see that stoning was the punishment for adultery in the Jewish Law and that in the case of Jewish offenders, this punishment was resorted to by the Holy Prophet Muhammad( pbuh) when he was the ruler of Medinah. Was the same punishment given to Muslims in Medinah at any time? Yes. It is true that the same punishment was given in certain cases when the offenders were Muslims. BUT CERTAINLY THIS WAS BEFORE THE REVELATION OF THE QURANIC VERSE 24:2. “ As for the adulteress and the adulterer-flog each of them with a hundred stripes, and let not compassion with them keep you from this law of God, if you believe in God and the Last Day; and let a group of the believers witness their chastisement” 24:2 Verse 24:2 speaks of MILD flogging, aiming at disgracing the offenders rather than torturing. The number of those to witness has been deliberately left unspecified, thus indicating that while the mild punishment must be given publicly, it need not be made a ‘public spectacle’. The Arabic word for flogging is JALD( means: skin). In other words, the punishment by flogging should be felt only by the skin. It aims more at disgracing the culprits rather than torturing them. Hence the Holy Quran positively excludes death or stoning to death. In fact, anyone who does deep research and objective interpretation of the Quranic Verse 4: 25, can see that, all possibilities of death as a punishment for adultery are precluded. Verse 4.25 gives the law on punishing for immoral conduct (fornication) Of believing maidens ( the community rightfully possess) They shall be liable to HALF the penalty to which free married women are liable. The weaker social status of a slave woman makes her, obviously more accessible to sexual temptation than a free married woman is presumed to be. Now the important point here is to understand that the number of 100 flogging can be halved but death or stoning to death can never be halved. So it is very clear that the Holy Quran speaks about flogging not death as a punishment for adultery. Now the question arises: Why did the prophet punish the Muslim adulterers making use of the Laws of Moses? The answer is, it was the Prophet’s practice to follow the earlier revealed law until he received an amended and a definite law on a specific wrong doing. People well versed in the evolution of Islamic law knew that drinking of alcohol was not prohibited in the beginning. People were not allowed to come to pray being drunk, but drinking itself was not forbidden until much later. The same thing was true about personal money lending and charging interest on personal loan as it was practised by Abbas (raa) The revelation about the prohibition on interest on personal lending was received just a short while before the death of the Prophet. The interpretation of the Quranic laws have been continuously developing and evolving and scholars have been elaborating and making changes to the earlier interpretations. Quran is the one and the only miracle of Islam. The adoring beauty of the Quran is that it throws a different light or a new light according to the time. No scholar’s interpretation on the Quran is the last word or final. Taqi ad Din Ahmad ibn Taymiyah ( 8th century’s greatest scholar)or Razi or Abu Muslim, might have given an interpretation on a particular Verse, but a great scholar like Shah Waliyullah ( 18th century) might have differed from that interpretation. And now in the 21st century, Sheikh Qaradawi may find earlier interpretations highly objectionable on several counts and give a totally different meaning to the same Verse based on the particular circumstances of the society now. The beauty of the Quran is that there is absolutely no change in the original revealed words but interpretations keep changing according to the environment, circumstances, facts and lives of people. People who are going to live in the 25th century may find new light in the Quran that the present day scholars have never dreamt of. Moreover, it is also for the Shariyah judge to decide the sort of punishment to be given to suit the circumstances. Great latitude is allowed to the judge in the choice of punishments. So what we need is stronger Iman and deeper research in order to understand the immense wisdom behind the Qu’ranic laws. We should not jump to hasty conclusions. If all the trees are turned into pens and all the seas are turned into ink, the pens and the ink will be exhausted but God’s words will never be exhausted. Modern man thinks he is too intelligent and hence foolishly questions even some of the most accepted Quranic ethics probably because he wants to compete with the fast changing decadent Western culture and try to appease and apologize. There is nothing to apologize in the laws of One True Almighty God. God knew Best.

  • Alexander Barnett 06/14/2010 11:44:00 PM

    I agree with the three previous letters completely. Yes, women have made progress in certain parts of the world, but overall the situation is horrific. Women must,of course, continue to fight for their basic human rights, but until men support their cause in large numbers things will not change sifnificantly. Final thought. Interesting that there are only three letters in response to this atrocious situation, but if Israel had committed atrocities just half as bad, their would be more like 300 letters protesting their typical inhuman behavior. This is typical selective outrage.

  • James 05/18/2010 8:01:00 AM

    I can't believe that this still exist today! It is horrific and immoral. I can't believe that no one in government had taken an assertive step towards demolishing this law! I am doing a Social Injustice report and believe this is the perfect case to right about. In our constitution it says "all men are created equal" It is now not only for men but for women to. Why is is that women in the middle east are being degraded and used? They are no lower than men. How can a women protect herself from being raped? If she is raped she is forced to have sex and is taken advantage of, and this is her fault? She has done wrong? What about the man who did this to her? Are charges not pressed against them? And I can't believe that murder, if done by a man is only 7 years, while forcibly having your virginity taken or simply being forced to have sex incriminates the women. Does anyone else see the insanity of this? This is clearly unjust and should be handled with delicacy. I believe it is a complicated situation, but i feel that it needs to be taken care of immediately. How can we call ourselves human when we kill each other for sport or for unjust cause, that is not humanity. That is monstrous....

  • Ann 03/24/2010 1:39:00 AM

    I watched the Stoning of Soraya M. the other night and was horrified. Horrified at human nature and horrified at the laws. Soraya was set up---as many of these women are. No one deserves to b stoned, even if guilty. Has no one heard of forgveness and redemption? AND they have to answer to God one day. All women should become a single voice for these women that it is already to late to save, and for those it is not to late to save. They are our sisters.

  • Tom Zart 07/04/2009 10:37:00 AM

    THE STONING OF WOMEN There are those who still stone women And we all know who they are. They live in a world cursed by God Where they murder mislead and scar. They need no proof to denounce their wives Of adultery, betrayal and worthlessness. They hate all religions except their own As they promote fear, death and hopelessness. Never turn a blind eye toward wickedness Instead support its defeat and demise. Hearts consumed by the shadows of malice Are terrified of the righteous and the wise. The stoning of women is a performance from hell And any country that allows it, will fail. All men heed to the whispers of their soul May goodness, and compassion take heed and prevail. By Conservative Poet Tom Zart Most Published Poet On The Web

 

Most Popular Stories


Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy