The God-squad answer to Todd Graff’s Camp, this after-church special finds chaste cover girl Hilary Duff playing a red-state songbird who, when her beloved brother dies in a car wreck after a Christian emo show (Jesus evidently wants him for a sunbeam), decides to buck their toothpick-chomping daddy’s rules and sneak off to a summer music program in scary urban L.A. Adorable Britboy Oliver James valiantly competes for second billing with Duff’s camera-hogging silver cross talisman necklace. We’re supposed to be rooting for this left-behind sister in her struggle to hit “Hallelujah Chorus” high notes, but all we can do is marvel at how the mighty—Northern Exposure hottie John Corbett (as a weirdly flirty music teacher) and Risky Business babe Rebecca De Mornay (as Duff’s frisky aunt)—have fallen.

This article from the Village Voice Archive was posted on September 28, 2004

Archive Highlights