By Christian Viveros-Fauné
By Miriam Felton-Dansky
By Tom Sellar
By Tom Sellar
By Jessica Dawson
By Tom Sellar
By R. C. Baker
By Tom Sellar
At best, all we can hope for from the theatrical moment is a temporary release from the agony outside: a few hours' purgation by laughter, or by pity and terror. Notice, by the way, what human dignity that stale old phrase carries compared to "shock and awe." By focusing our feelings on a few people in a simple situation, the theater can restore our sense of humanity. Interestingly, it's the only art that can: Movies and TV are inhuman technological artifacts; music is abstract; books and pictures are solitary pastimes. Only in the theater can we be with the people living out an experience, and feel that we share it in some waya feeling that the very real images of the war, whether on TV or in newsprint, can't give you; they only increase your sense of rage and helplessness. True, you can't help Hamlet or Willy Loman or Lysistrata either, but at least you're there with them. In that respect, as it turns out, they can help you.
It's at that point precisely that the innocuousness of commercial entertainment becomes its biggest drag. A play's substance is embodied in its characters; the less substantial the play, the more shadowy its people. The two couples in Yasmina Reza's Life (x) 3, for instance, aren't people at all; they're merely one of the standard bridge-table matchups of sketch comedy, one pair of insecure bickerers and a snootier pair a few rungs above them on the status ladder. Where Reza learned all the standard tropes of 1940s Broadway comedy (from which sitcom proceeds) I don't know; surely Franco-Iranian writers don't spend their lives delving into the likes of Norman Krasna. She dresses the material up in fancy Structuralist clothes with metaphysical ruffles, but there's no concealing its sitcomic nature. Yes, the pompous couple show up for dinner on the wrong night, just when the bickersons' bratty offstage offspring is driving them nuts. Yes, hubby bickerson's having career trouble; yes, his wife still resents giving up hers; yes, the pompous boss has a letch for wifey (this is a French play, after all); yes, boss's stuffy wife has a few too many and says giddy wrong things. If there's anyone still reading who thinks they couldn't write this script better themselves, it's back to rerun school for you.
The Play What I Wrote
By Hamish MacColl
Seventh Avenue and 45th Street
By Aaron Latham and Philip Oesterman,
songs by Jason Robert Brown et al.
Broadway and 44th Street
Reza's gimmick is to replay the embarrassing non-dinner party three times, with the characters' relations shifting slightly each time, like numerical permutations. Her mistake was assuming that this would add up to an evening of theater; instead it simply shows that she might have written the play any of three different ways if she had only found some reason to care about its characters. But she didn't, and so neither do we: They remain bits of cardboard next to whom the figures in more current sitcoms look almost three-dimensional. Matthew Warchus's direction worsens matters by staging everything at a stately pace, to make sure we get all the jokes. He needn't have bothered; most of them are visible a long way off, rather like the exits at Circle in the Square. John Turturro works mightily hard, sometimes to good effect, to animate this non-party's beleaguered host; if his moves and inflections sometimes suggest a mixture of Ralph Kramden and Ricky Ricardo, you can hardly blame him for honoring the author's sources. Linda Emond, Helen Hunt, and Brent Spiner bear their lesser afflictions with skill and patience; all four should be rewarded in the near future with the script of something worth playing.
It's no use playing down to Sean Foley, Hamish MacColl, and Toby Jones, the three clowns who make up the cast of The Play What I Wrotethey'll only agree with you, make six lame jokes, fold themselves in half, and move on to the next bit. The attenuated variety show what they put on, full of ancient vaudeville and music-hall wheezes which you can also often see approaching from miles off, has its moments of laughter. But, as Rossini said about Wagner's music, it has an even greater number of mauvais quarts d'heure. Vaudeville and music-hall comedy acts ran 10 to 20 minutes, and then had the sense to get offstage; trying to stretch one into a two-hour theater evening with the barest pretense of continuity requires a kind of inspiration, or maybe a degree of emotional focus, that's not in this team or its material. Having a surprise celebrity guest each night may enhance the treat, but doesn't enrich its substance, since each mystery guest is put through an equivalent set of insipid jokes.