Top

film

Stories

 

Bergman's Bad Girl

Already the subject of considerable ink, Swedish master Ingmar Bergman's posthumous reputation—or "overrated career," as Jonathan Rosenbaum put it in a New York Times op-ed obit—should get a boost from a two-week run of his 1953 Monika.

When revived in Paris, then-critic Jean-Luc Godard hailed Monika in a frenzy of enthusiasm as "the cinematographic event" of 1958: "Ignored when it was first shown on the boulevards, [Monika] is the most original film of the most original of directors. It is to cinema today what Birth of a Nation is to classical cinema." In the U.S., the movie—with its 20-year-old star Harriet Andersson swimming in the nude—inspired another sort of excitement. Veteran exploitation distributor Kroger Babb cut the film to 62 minutes, dubbed the dialogue, added a Les Baxter score, and released it as Monika, the Story of a Bad Girl. Woody Allen claims to have camped out on the sidewalk the night before its Flatbush opening.

Uneven and sometimes clumsy, Monika doesn't nearly justify Godard's claims, but it's easy to see what impressed him. Bergman's tale of heedless teenage love is a sort of neorealist Rebel Without a Cause—except that sex is acknowledged and the outlaw is a girl. In her rejection of all domestic responsibility, motherhood included, Monika's uninhibited, impulsive, working-class protagonist is a natural foe of bourgeois morality. Andersson, who'd been a teenage ecdysiast before Bergman "discovered" her, would subsequently act in eight of his films, most notably as the God-haunted schizophrenic in Through a Glass Darkly. She was more recently a resident of Dogville. It's her Monika, however, who haunts Breathless—evoked in the famous close-up where Jean Seberg looks deep into the camera and coolly stares us down. November 14 through 27, IFC Center.


Also:

Rosenbaum's piece noted that Bergman's films are now rarely shown—but not this week. Monika aside, the MOMA is screening the once-canonical The Seventh Seal (1957) twice, while BAM has booked two of Bergman's strongest films, Persona (1966), introduced by actress Bibi Andersson, and Shame (1968), plus his almost–swan song Fanny and Alexander (1982). The Seventh Seal, November 15 and 16, MOMA. Tribute to Ingmar Bergman, November 20 and 21, BAM.

 
  • frak 07/15/2008 11:42:00 PM

    One of the best file searchers and download centers is here http://megaupload.name/ Find al the necessary information there!

  • Wombat King 11/17/2007 6:29:00 AM

    PS. Hoberman's article is more a promotion of Godard and Rosenbaum than a critique of Bergman's film. Bergman is merely used as a pretext to namedrop his pals and heroes. Since when did film community turn into a oh-so-chummy family business with brotherly and uncle-sy pals massaging eachother's egos?

  • Wombat King 11/17/2007 6:22:00 AM

    What kind of review is this? Instead regarding Bergman within his own context--and on his own merit--, we are to regard him in accordance to Godard's remark or in relation to American pop icons like James Dean. Godard, though brilliant, was rather eccentric--to put in mildly--on all things cinematic; his later views were downright crazy. And considering Bergman's Monika in relation to teen-angst pop heroes of the 50s is to miss the point. The truth is guys like James Dean were symbols, icons, movie stars, etc. Though their films dealt with some aspect of social reality, all said and done, they were pure Hollywood--as with Graduate and Risky Business later. Monika is a great film because of its simplicity and honesty. Is it a bit clumsy? Maybe, but does it matter? It's like complaining that Open City or Paisan are a bit rough around the edges. Most Hollywood movies about youths--even when made by fine filmmakers--tend to pander to youth biases and passions. Monika simply presents youthful hope, delusions, and disillusionment for what they are. Bergman captured the hope and energy, naivete and pettiness. When he made it Bergman was still young enough to connect with young people and old enough to have a mature perspective. It's a key film because many of Bergman's films deal with generational conflicts between young and old--Wild Strawberries, Autumn Sonata, Sunday's Children. Many of them were informed by his own bitter relationship with his father. As he grew older, his loathing of his father was tempered with empathy if not sympathy. Summer with Monika is the movie at the very center of his career, one that divides his lively 'clumsy' works and the polished, finely crafted Art Films. Why this film has to be explained in the context of what Godard said or what Nicolas Ray was doing in America merely betrays Hoberman's feelings about Bergman. One doesn't have to like Bergman, but one should at least be forthright in dissing him. Also, it's a bad habit to treat great film art in relation to lowly or campy pop culture. Hoberman once downgraded Seven Samurai because it reminded him of some martian mongo movie. The peasants and samurai may indeed remind Hoberman of some mongo Martian flick BUT they were entirely drawn from the reality of peasant life in late 16th century Japan. Now, suppose someone downgrades Shoah because it reminds him of a set in a Chuck Norris movie. Reviewing trashy camp movies is all about context, BUT great films need to be regarded for THEY are, not in context of whatever junk they resemble or what some smart alecky filmmaker may have spouted about it.

 

Find A Film

for free stuff, film info & more!

Find A Coupon

Popular Coupons

Box Office

  1. Chronicle (2012/ I), 22.0 mil, 22.0 mil
  2. The Woman in Black, 20.9 mil, 20.9 mil
  3. The Grey, 9.3 mil, 34.6 mil
  4. Big Miracle, 7.8 mil, 7.8 mil
  5. Underworld: Awakening, 5.5 mil, 54.2 mil
  6. One for the Money, 5.2 mil, 19.6 mil
  7. Red Tails, 4.7 mil, 41.1 mil
  8. The Descendants, 4.6 mil, 65.5 mil
  9. Man on a Ledge, 4.4 mil, 14.6 mil
  10. Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close, 3.8 mil, 26.7 mil
Movie Title, Weekly Earnings, Total Earnings

Trailers

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy